OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

Sky's already spoken. He said he didn't investigate anyone because he was unable to get online due to work and family issues

 

Yet he did get investigated apparently? So you have to admit someone (other than me) suspected him or why investigate him?

 

We already did. Milk found my voting of Billy inconsistent and, given that he aleady had me down as a potential suspect if Lucaaas was guilty, voted for me. I decided to therefore be consistent in my pattern of voting for people who vote for me and switched to him. I also did a post a couple of pages back where I went through my thoughts on everyone.

 

I really don't want to go over old ground but you keep making these claims so again, why...?

 

It sounds like it's split in two.

Billy thinks afc n bod are suspicious (possible mafia hanging up) and they both think he is mafia.

I guess if afc or bod go and 1 is innocent then it proves re other is innocent and billy is mafia? Right? Or have I got this wrong.... (Most probably)

 

Danilo investigated Milk second night. If no other cop comes forward, we have to assume that Danilo and Sky were innocent at the time. Therefore, at least one of Milk and Bodanki was innocent second night. Worst case scenario: One was being covered by the snitch and the other has now been converted...

 

I'm not saying Bod is the Don (despite you still seeming to suggest he's 100% innocent AFC) all I'm saying is on the second night (had I been Don) I'd have protected myself as no-one else from the mafia was under threat from lynching. Why would the Don take the chance of himself being investigated to protect a goon, snitch or inestigator? That makes no sense. From my point of view (as an innocent) I still have to consider that whoever was investigated second night was protected....unlikely but are you denying it is a possibility?

 

Well, AFC as made him and Bod a easy target for the mafia. I believe Bod is innocent as there are two fairly clear things pointing to this; Sky investigation and Lucaas (a known mafia) voting for Bod in the first round.

The fact remains that AFC didn't know Bod was innocent at first, it started as a hunch. The fact they appear to be acting as a team as no foundation unless they are both mafia and as I've just said above, I think Bod is a townie.

Bod being innocent in way way shape or form means AFC is innocent either. However, AFC's contribution would suggest he is innocent anyway since he as pointed the finger at every single person involved in the game by the end of the second day!

 

It's obvious me and bod are innocent.

Billy got saved from danger every time he was in it yesterday. He decided that because hash voted for me and then got whacked that I obviously did it and tried to get others to vote for me. No-one went for it so he switched to Bodanki. Using the whacked person as a way to try and make another an obvious target? That's gotta be a mafia move. On top of strange voting patterns and strange certainty of my guilt based on hash dying, he has also remained ever present in the thread, influencing things without directly getting himself involved. Acting all squeaky clean.

Thre are plenty of reasons to suspect billy.

 

Take a wild guess

 

I wouldn't react if he said he thought you was a target, thats fair enough. Its words like "obvious" and "clear" that I question. As far as I can see, nothing is obvious or clear bar a couple me

 

I think it's highly unlikely. There were other people who looked far more likely to be investigated and they are the ones likely to be protected. There was no mention of Bodanki being investigated and he has been constantly in the firing line. His strategy makes no sense if he is the don.

Everything we have points to Bodanki having the best chance of being innocent of anyone playing tbh...

Anyone who tries to put him as a leading candidate for mafia now is obviously ignoring logic to suit some other agenda.

 

Ok I'm voting billy as Bod n afc seem to really suspect him and Gerrez thinks bod n afc are both innocent so wouldn't make sense for them to gang up and be so convinced otherwise?

 

Sorted

 

Again totally misrepresenting me. Do you concede Bod could still POSSIBLY be mafia (or anyone other than me )?

 

You total bellend Thanks for the support fellow Red

 

I'm so confused between who to believe, you or them!!!

 

I think it is very, very unlikely Bodanki is mafia, unless he was converted last night. But I don't see why they would go for him.

Of course there are other mafia than you... There's more than one left to find... But your still mafia

 

I want clarification of who was investigated which night by as we seem to be basing their innocence on that.

 

Yes or no will do do you concede that as townies we can't totally discount him yet?