OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

Because Lucaas was already under suspicion, and his role as investigator was worthless once all the people with roles had been outed.
For them to suggest an unknown goon who has not as of yet been suspected, would have looked dodgy.
In short, they needed a bandwagon they were sure people would jump on to spare Billy......That was Lucaas

 

In the first round AFC wanted you dead most of the time. He changed his mind last minute and he's been your dedicated disciple ever since. That's without a actual reason throughout day two and some of day three until Sky announced he'd investigated you.

Bullshit, I was questioning it the whole time

Anyway, that's no longer relevant and is side stepping the point about why you guys are voting for Billy.

 

You've even said yourself that voting was erratic when billy was in danger...

 

Voting patterns changed to put me under threat in the first place I hadn't had any votes until AFC and Bod got together. Why is Bod completely innocent? He could be the snitch....or just a total div

 

ATM, no I can't. So far...

Dead Townies: RHC, Magic & Hash

Dead Mafia: Lucaas

Town Investigators: Sky & Danilo

Doctor: Gerrez

Townies: Bodanki

Leftover: Milk, Nozzer, Minxy, afcftw, ibwt, billy & Astro

The Don: ?

The Mafia Goon: ?

The Snitch: ?

The Converted: ?

 

And billy is the only person who tried to use hash's death to get an advantage...

Hash fingered me, hash gets whacked, billy uses hash's death as a reason to vote for me and claim undoubtedly I'm mafia (when I know I'm not) which IBWT jumps on immediately. Myself and Bodanki then vote for billy, others suggest they may suspect billy too and all of a sudden the votes move and I'm in the clear, Bodanki is in danger and billy isn't out as the front runner.

Then there was attempts to make it a three way vote instead of a two way vote which would of given him cover and again at the last minute billy was the obvious choice to make the second runner to lucaaas but even when people started moving votes from lucaaas they didn't return to billy but instead there was a shift towards Bodanki.

The voting around billy makes no sense if he is a towns person.

 

Fair point on the investigator being worthless although so is the goon position really. We didn't know Lucaas was a investigator though, nor did we suspect him.

 

Anyone noticed Gerrez writing letters with his left hand instead of his right hand (which he previously wrote with), since the last round.

Thats a "V" reference, for those who dont know.

 

I did, and so did afcftw. I even said so, we just couldnt get the other knuckleheads to follow suit.

 

Indeed, lucaaas even shouted me down for suggesting him.

 

I've already noted you hadn't had any votes prior to that. Doesn't change the fact that every time you had the most votes things changed very quickly.

I believe Bod is innocent because Sky said so AND because Lucaas voted for Bod in the first round putting Bod in danger prior to AFC's last second change. If Bod is mafia then so is AFC and I sincerely doubt that they employ such a risky strategy in the first round, especially thirty seconds from the deadline!

 

That was me (jokingly) and Milk (actual did it), not Billy!

 

.

 

Billy doesn't have to arrange the vote change publicly for him to benefit from the suggested changes. Doesn't clear him at all! Just slightly implicates you and milk in my theory... But again that is only a small part of the very obvious weird voting surrounding. Illy.

 

Is that you suggesting I've been converted?

So a bit like you guys did with Billy, don't see eye to eye so they must be the opposite team despite me clearly defending you

I've been on here all day and read every comment (sad I know but being off ill and bored does that) and I didn't see one mention from you guys to try and swing things towards Lucaas. things changed after Danilo's announcement.

 

The way I see it, again from the viewpoint that I am the only one I know 100% is innocent.

1) Billy is the Don and Lucaas was sacrificed to save him. I had previously thought Gerrez innocent, but could he have been converted? Eliminating the doctor would severely weaken us, plus he already said he was protecting himself, so arranging a hit against him would be worthless.
2) Afcftw was the one converted and is leading me down a merry path of lies (this is extremely unlikely imo, but possible, and if he was converted he is doing an awesome job).

People keep commenting on us "teaming up", but I do geniunely believe we have just spotted something no one else has.

The Zeal with which Gerrez is defending Billy, despite him saying he knows I am innocent, is somewhat troubling. We may have discovered who was converted!!

 

Lucaaas was definitely put forward by myself and Bodanki. It didn't gather any momentum though and we didn't change votes off billy to him. And that was well before danilo made his claim.

 

That'll be me, the proclaimed doctor that no one as question and most believe to be the most trust worthy person in the game as a result prior to this round right? Its not the first time you've questioned me but don't worry, I won't take it personally like you and Bod did with Billy

 

Set up alert woooo

The voting pattern changed when Bod and AFC decided It didn't change away from me until Danilo outed a guilty man...Bod and AFC must have been gutted

 

I couldn't pull off being converted this coolly