OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

Look, maybe I'm being harsh on you so I'll leave this for now...

 

Because Lucaas voted for Bod in the first round when Bod was in a two way fight with RHC.

 

It was you who started the campaign against me Why was that? Have I voted suspiciously? Nope...have I layed low....nope, have I said anything out of order, not really (apart from I was convinced Magic was up to no good but he was just being useless lol). I've explained my reasonings for all my votes too Can you say the same?

 

Before it was unanimous that the town had decided Danilo was telling the truth not Lucaaas. It was still early enough that it could have gone the other way- and those 4 came in quick succession.

 

With you on this for sure.
I was the first to vote for Billy in the last round, only switching to Lucaas last thing when it looked like we had a real chance of getting rid of Lucaas (whom I strongly suspected was guilty).
Other than my initial vote for RHC, I have been more or less spot on with these guesses and so has afcftw. Yet people still don't want to listen.

Lucaas made sacrificed by the mafia when it became clear Billy was in the frame.
Yes you could argue that they wouldnt get rid of their investigator before their goon, but Lucaas was under suspicion by many (hence the amount of votes he got), so they knew he was the safest bet to put out there on the chopping block.

 

I'm leaving for the evening... goodness knows how many pages will be here when I get back but.

Nozzer and IBWT are both almost certainly guilty.
Astro might be too- but I'm prepared to cut him a little slack.
Minxy -small chance she is guilty instead of Astro.

AFC keeps making himself look guilty- but unless he was converted last night I think he's actually probably innocent.

 

I saw that and I've pointed it out to Billy. I voted for Billy at one stage too remember.

As for the "its your opinion", I'm not on my own in saying that because when it comes to Bod, thats all it is.

 

Your main charge against me was not bothering to move from Billy to Lucaaas, and then voting for Billy again. I explained my reasons. I've made several posts in reply to yours which you have either ignored or only paritally answered, so that's a bit disingenious.

As for Astro and IBWT: IBWT looks genuinely confused to me and seems to be mainly trying to do what you wanted. I'm more suspicious of Astro, but have nothing concrete against him.

 

I haven't cleared you yet 100% Bod. Still possible you were protected by snitch when Sky looked at you... especially if you're the Don! Low down on my list of targets now though.

 

Thank **** it's not just me noticing it! Started thinking I was going crazy!

 

Fair enough, sounds reasonable.

 

Ditto, you backed me in the first round, but I am well aware that could very likely be a ploy to win my trust.

 

I think Danilo was genuine. But that neither incriminates nor spares Billy.

 

I'm not guilty.. just lost

Your marking me as guilty for trying to following Gerrez's plan to split the votes at the last minute when confusion was all around

 

I should have put with, my mistake. Point still stands and a refer to a earlier point:

First night Billy voted for me, Lucaas went for Bod
Second night they both went for Magic
Third night Billy voted for Lucaas, Lucaas went for Bod

So I ask again, how did Billy vote with Lucaas twice...?

 

It was looking pretty likely to go that way though.

 

Are you seriously trying to suggest I haven't explained why I think Bodanki is innocent yet beyond just having a hunch? I've written it out maybe ten times so far, literally.

Once again. Sky is an investigator, not disputed by anyone, he says Bodanki is innocent, no reason to believe otherwise. Bodanki has been in harms way far too much to be the don so no reason for the snitch to cover him. All the evidence points to him being innocent. Anyone who thinks otherwise is ignoring the logic we are presented with or is mafia IMO

 

I think he means on the thrid night, Billy was voting with Lucaaas for Bod until Danilo piped up and people started switching. Billy then went with the flow (regardless of whether innocent or guilty).

 

Oh my god.. Your doing my head in. Just read my posts properly.

Ok, billy voted for Bodanki in the last round a long with lucaaas. This happened. This isn't up for debate. This is fact. Billy then changed his vote to lucaaas when it looked obvious lucaaas would die.

It isn't rocket science to figure out my point...

 

Anyway, night people.

please log in to view this image