OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

Agreed

Lucaas' guilt does clear Bod though. Plus Danilo said Milk was innocent too.

 

Right. So how does me sticking with Billy on the next day suddenly implicate me? I was voting for him before Danilo came out, and other than Lucaaas being the mafia investigator, we have no new information, certainly none on Billy. So surely I was being consistent in sticking with my vote?

 

So Nozzer, instead of you, should I vote for IBWT or Astro in your eyes... since at least one of the three of you is almost certainly Mafia. (probably 2 or 3 of you)

 

Why, because I'm being consistent? I was saying this to you before Lucaas' death, I'm just not being as tactful any more

If there was suspicion they show us the facts. Not your opinion or feelings, we want the quotes and links, the evidence of what you claim!

I did tell you quite early in this game that you weren't doing yourself any favours. I think most are ignoring your claims now as you've gone on about it far too much for anyone to believe you. and that's coming from someone that as said you are innocent too!!!

 

I don't think danilo saved him. I think that was a lucky side show that saved billy.

More than once billy looked in danger and each time the vote changed very quickly to keep him out of danger.

Even if you don't think he is guilty, surely he is under enough suspicion to have him up against someone else for the chop until we get any new info? If he isn't the mafia no-one will help him.

 

No because that isn't what happened. People are suspicious of billy for more than just him and Bodanki having a spat....

 

How so? I tend to think he is innocent because of Sky, but not sure how you get that from Lucaaas.

Still uncertain about Milk, especially after the conversion.

 

When it was suggested that we split the vote between Lucaas and one other, I went for Billy before Gerrez and someone else went for someone else (can't remember who now) so thtat's why I changed to them, then got proper confused and changed to Lucaaas again as it was decided no one was splitting votes

In truth, I had no idea what was happening

 

I believe the last round of votes was the first time he'd been voted for at all, I could be wrong though

 

121 pages - this game is legendary

 

Oh, maybe? I dno, I'm lost

 

In my mind, the most currently suspicious people are Billy and you, so I would say vote for one of them two for now. Everyone else I'm unsure on. I trust no-one.

 

Other than the fact that Billy ONCE cast a vote with Lucaaas- and hasn't been voted off yet- I don't see any reason to vote Billy off... it makes absolutely no sense. I think everyone has voted the same as Lucaaas at least once. (probably except for the real mafia ) - if someone can cast a real reason why Billy is numero uno other than he voted with Lucaaas against Magic- tell me.

In the meantime- it just seems a distraction away from 3 perfectly rational targets (4) if you consider Minxy's latish switch to Lucaaas... although she is a less target.

Billy was one of the first to jump on Lucaaas (away from Bod who was still a real target at the time Billy switched).

 

Only four?

How had Billy voted for Lucaas twice in a row? I just said Billy voted for me in the first round and Magic in the second!

Look, I'm not defending Billy at all. I don't know whether he is innocent or guilty and the last round gives us nothing to help with that either. I just find your case a bit, well, laughable.

 

I said Bodanki was innocent, I didn't vote for magic, I called lucaaas before anyone else... And billy is obviously guilty...

Every time I post anything with explanation you just ignore them and go "so it's just your opinion" I had to explain that I thought Bodanki was innocent because of sky about ten times in a row before anyone accepted I was giving a valid reason...

Billy was more than once in line to die and every time the vote changed within minutes. That isn't opinion that is fact, it happened. Whether you find it suspicious is another matter, but I find it highly suspicious that he so quickly was taken out of harms way.

 

So you think Billy is the Don? And you believe the mafia decided to sacrifice their investigator before their goon or snitch...?

 

That's probably because your not reading my posts. In the quote your replying to I say he voted WITH lucaaas, not FOR lucaaas twice. Your arguing with points I'm not making.

What I said stands, he voted with lucaaas for magic and voted with lucaaas for Bodanki before changing to lucaaas when it was obvious he wasn't going to be saved. That is a fact, that is what happened, there is no conjecture or opinion involved in that.

 

The town knows I was innocent before night fall- and before night fall I said "IBWT, Astro, and Nozzer" are the main targets.
After daylight I still say the same thing. It's safe to say I'm innocent.

You three however, despite trying to push Billy as a red herring by you and IBWT (and the AI webbot known as AFC) haven't even really acknowledged why you might be guilty or even really look at each other as suspects. (which tends to make me think you're in cahoots... Astro off the hook a little because he hasn't been on- and his vote was in pattern with his others).

 

The fourth of six?

 

I think danilo is an investigator and called out lucaaas and so they had no choice.

Given only three towns people claimed to have roles, we have to assume you all told the truth, in which case there is no need for he him mafia investigator anymore, he hasn't use other than his vote. So it makes no difference as long as he isn't the don.