OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

Hope he gets better soon Sky

 

Well, sky didn't investigate so he's not going to tell is much is he lol

 

Feel for you pal. Been there a few times as you know, never nice.

 

We know at least one of them is telling the truth though- and it probably won't be hard to figure out which one depending on what they say. If you, Nozzer, and Astro are the rest of the Mafia team- we've got time on our hands to figure out which of Sky and Danilo is guilty.

It's actually a pretty good theory... only if I were on Mafia I would have pushed for my Don to use his convert on day 1.

 

Just trying to look at the not obvious.

I know I keep saying it, but Milk has a huge advantage given he's experienced in this game. He can use that experience to twist and if he's mafia, advise and pretty much run the mafia team from PM.

I'm not saying he defeinitely is, but first round he votes for RHC who was killed and innocent. 2nd round he votes for Magic who was killed and vigilante. 3rd round votes for Lucaaas who was killed and mafia (but could have been a sacrifice).

 

In which case you were either fishing for a conversion or you're a worse doctor than Jacko had

 

thanks

 

Never trust a bald Dr

#balding

please log in to view this image

 

Your theory about me, Danilo and Lucaaas being in cahoots though has a major hole. It was me who suggested that everyone announce their role and they did. There was never a third cop- so Danilo has to be a cop (at least before conversion last night) and therefore I couldn't have been in cahoots with Danilo!

So that theory isn't possible. We know Danilo WAS the cop (may still be).



Sorry... but logically IBWT- you have to accept that you, Nozzer and Astro are prime suspects... as I said... if you were innocent- surely you'd be questioning Nozzer and Astro- logically they are the most likely Mafia if you're not. Likewise they would have to question you.

So far none of you has put any suspicion on the others.

 

I find the sacrifice idea interesting. Bump one off whilst recruiting (recruition?) another. Risking since I could have protected them.

As for the Sky vs Danilo discussion. It was clear in the last round that I was unable to protect Sky. They didn't know whether I would protect myself or Danilo though. By this, Sky is the more likely to be converted.
Problem is, I trust Sky more than anyone else in this game. That's not 'I trust him', it's 'more than anyone else'.

 

I merely didn't like the landslide. Why did no one try to save him? It made me think he was innocent and Danilo was pulling a fast one.

I appreciate it was a bad move in the end.

 

It was a clever idea... until you realise that we know everyone's role. Only Sky and Danilo came forwards as cops- so unless someone is hiding their role - Danilo couldn't have been in cahoots with the Mafia Don- because he wasn't in the Mafia.

 

Indeed

 

Why does Danilo have to be a cop? Just because no one claimed it before him doesn't make it necessarily true. Maybe they didn't like your idea and didn't want to lose their animosity and remained quiet. Afc, Bodanki & minxy were very quiet (or not here) before Danilo claimed it. Maybe one of them is cop and wants to stay hidden and Danilo took a risk and giant bluff by claiming it then picking one of the fellow mafia people as a sacrifice to "prove" he was a good guy?

 

How do you know that?

The main fault I see with the sacrifice is, why the Mafia investigator? Why not the goon?

 

Nice instinct to have although- there were enough people holding back from voting for Lucaaas. (6 until IBWT and Minxy switched in the dying minutes) that the landslide didn't bother me (especially since we had Danilo. next if Lucaaas was dead.

Honestly- I expected more people to switch over- I figured even the Mafia had to realise he was a gonner and switch over to avoid suspicion.

 

Two people came forwards as cops. If one of them was lying (say Danilo) then it would have made sense for the real cop to have come forwards. They never did. Not even now.

 

Based on what? That we didn't join the landslide vote for Lucaaas? Why should we have when the outcome looked fairly certain? And IBWT and Astro basically seemed to be trying to do what you were doing. And no-one put any sort of push in to get Billy once Danilo declared. the closest came when I said there was a risk that we were downgrading our potential mafia kill - which you agreed with. I also pretty much said a 50/50 split on potential dons (if they were at all dons) was more of a risk than going Lucaaas. And that once we had Lucaaas, we had no real idea who he linked to. And that once the roles were revealed, hs investigative powers were useless.

 

Too obvious? Investigator wasn't needed with you and sky already revealing your roles?

 

But if Danilo lied about being a cop- why hasn't the real cop come forwards?