OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

Correct

 

I've already highlighted my psychic powers pointing at Minxy too

 

I never said you weren't mafia though

 

She is a woman though... God knows what's going on in that mind of hers

 

Don't speak ill of the dead Let's remember he was another innocent victim here

 

I never said you did You were still correct though

 

Hash who was just a normal towns person, decided i was guilty and voted for me (presumably after I had cast suspicion on him and then my odd vote), the mafia took the opportunity to whack hash and place the blame on me. Unfortunately hash played right into there hands by using his death message to assume him dieting guaranteed I was mafia, rather than seeing it for the obvious setup it was.

Billy has used hash's random suspicion on me which didn't have much of an explanation to start with as guaranteed proof im100% guilty... Why would that make him so certain? Especially after he has avoided being involved in incriminating anyone so far and is now pushing hard for me to become the favourite to go...

It's all too convenient, he's either mafia or lost the plot.

 

Obviously

 

Sexist pig

You won't get converted talking about her "kind" like that

 

I still consider that a strong possibility. Or you could have been doing your crazy strategy.

Or he could be trying to gain support. Mafia frequently point out innocents that they already know. Sky and Bod not necessarily on same team.

Gerrez also came out as Doctor- which at first I wonder if he did that to protect himself if Sky was the next one executed. However, no one has discredited his claim so he might be telling the truth. So far you've linked yourself to Bod- very plausible. And linked yourself to Sky and Gerrez illogically.

No- no link between you and Sky and Gerrez- just Astro and Bod.

Exactly- so if you're Mafia Gerrez isn't. If you're Mafia, I would assume from what you said that Sky and Gerrez probably aren't- and that you're trying to gain them as allies not to suspect you.

Unless someone else comes out as the Doctor- I'm assuming Gerrez is telling the truth.

Probably, although I suspect the Mafia spread their vote out, because they could. There are so many "singleton" votes out there for people without any strong reason behind them.

I was implying if they came out fingering a Mafia. Obviously, I've been vocal in my suspicion of Sky. He came out under very suspicious circumstances. Him and Magic to just reveal themselves like that seemed very counter-town. Plus statistically (which I've had wrong all along- 4 town roles not 3... not that anyone corrected me) had them as being most likely Mafia.

Doesn't have to be Don twice in a row. Chance of him being Mafia are 1 in 3. 1 in 3 people left are Mafia. Chance of any of us being Mafia is 1 in 3.

 

I'm willing to bet- because there wasn't a close contest last night that the Mafia had a split vote strategically last night.

I keep coming back to the Bod-Astro-AFC triangle. It could be that one of them isn't Mafia. Bod seems to be in the center of it all though.
We do know that Sky says Bod is innocent. But we don't know that Sky is honest.

So we know that if Bod is guilty Sky must be. (or small chance fooled by the snitch last night).

If Bod is Mafia. Sky most likely is. And Astro and AFC are both prime suspects.

Unfortunately because last night had only one front runner and so many outliers... nothing. By the town scattering their votes like they are they're making it easier for the Mafia to hide.

 

I said quite early on in this game that I'd done a table to keep track of things that stood out to me during this game. this was going well until I got sent home (ill) from work yesterday. Not been in today either so the table as gone unused for two days and I can't get to it

 

Sent home?

****ing under the desk again?

 

(I already said I believe Gerrez is innocent but...)

Why would a doctor ever come out? He would be a big target and doesn't need anyone to "believe" in him to do his job like a cop does.

I think Gerrez only came out because there was suspicion he had a role anyway so he might as well, but generally the doctor should remain hidden.

 

Not just that though is it Your voting has been scattergun and chasing/trying to influence voting on a regular basis Hash's accusation brings all that into very sharp focus that's why.

And why am I under suspicion again? For being active? Or for pointing the finger at two with serious irregularities in voting (unlike me in fairness) with a more valid reason than "well you voted for me so I'm voting for you" kinda thing.

#letthepeopledecide

 

If Gerrrez is the Dr, It would be wise to save me tonight if he can?

I'm 70% sure who the don is.

 

Yep. There may even be no Mafia in the magic vote. Doubt it, I reckon there will be at least one but it was so one sided they could have voted for anyone.

What I did find interesting though is I only suspect three players as the Don and two of them voted for Milk in the last round.

 

If only

 

Billy trust me Bod is innocent - don't waste your vote mate.

 

Your correct. Your voting isn't irregular, it's been for an innocent person who has ended up, or almost ended up dead in both rounds.

My votes however have not been for either person who has been lynched and I've accused just about everyone, which has given some interesting responses and vote changes.