OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

please log in to view this image

WTF! I'm not top Interesting...

 

the fact i commented so much is interesting i thought i was staying out of it

REMINDER: to those with ROLES... bank your actions early. then you can change. PM me anytime

 

Milk, minxy, Astro, sky and billy are all suspicious....looking back through the votes there is quite possibly connections between these players.

Milk has also voted for someone who has died on both days.

 

[table="width: 500, class: grid, align: left"]
[tr]
[td]Vote:[/td]
[td]no of votes[/td]
[td]By:[/td]
[/tr]
[tr]
[td]sky[/td]
[td]1[/td]
[td]milk[/td]
[/tr]
[tr]
[td]bodanki[/td]
[td]1[/td]
[td]nozzer[/td]
[/tr]
[tr]
[td]minxy[/td]
[td]1[/td]
[td]bodanki[/td]
[/tr]
[tr]
[td]milk[/td]
[td]1[/td]
[td]AFCFTW[/td]
[/tr]
[/table]

Not voted:, minxy, danilo, lucaas, ibwt,billy,sky, astro, gerrez


thanks for clearing all up

 

Since Magic got the majority of votes, that was always going to be the case for one or two though.

 

The people who voted for magic were to unwavering in there votes. Definitely some mafia amongst them.

 

And at least one mafia will have gone for Bodanki as a late runner to throw off suspicion

 

Why exactly am I suspicious? I've given valid reasons for each of my votes, Gerrez for his PM blunder and Magic for being hopeless You on the other hand have tossed and turned more than Frank (aka Kellie) Maloney.....why is that? Plus the innocent Hash fingered you on his deathbed

 

I suspect the Don will go for one of three people:

1) Bodanki (because Sky's claimed him to be innocent. Continue the theme of either framing him or proving Sky right)

2) Sky (because he's said he is a cop and they know I protected him last night)

3) Me (because I've announced my role but I've also said I will be protecting myself tonight too)

I don't know whether the Don will opt for a kill or conversion though. I'd have expected a conversion by now and I certainly expected something to happen in the first round too so the Don's movements are a bit unpredictable atm

 

Lucaaaaas, milk, gerrez, Astro, billy, skylarker

That's the votes for magic and the order. Milk helped get the idea of magic as a suspect rolling, will be interesting to go back and see who pushed for it with him.

Sky voted fairly late to guarantee magic was going to go. Astro, gerrez and billy picked him and didn't change there votes at any point.

 

Genuine mistake as I didn't know I had a PM at the time. I've since announced I do have a role too

 

I'd say minimum two of those voting for magic are mafia.

 

Gerrez is peddling the idea that him and sky are telling the truth so I'm thinking there is a clear possible link there.

Looking back to see if there are other links now.

 

Where have a pushed that idea?

Look at number one above. I clearly say framing or proving him right. In other words, I don't know if he's telling the truth or not but his only claim so far (Hash being innocent) proved to be true.

He could be telling the truth, hence him knowing Hash was innocent. He could be lying in which case he'd know Hash was a townie. If he is mafia investigator then he could have known Hash was a innocent townie.

 

What I don't get is why they bumped Hash last night. They must have felt he was the investigator or else why not just convert him and have an extra mafia that no-one had even suspected very much? Is that their first big mistake?

please log in to view this image

Ok I'm gonna trust Hash's instincts for now and go with AFC ​ Hash suspected him then Hash got bumped....I'm off to fetch the hangin rope

 

Astro and gerrez can be linked if they made a clever move in the first round. Astro voted late to throw gerrez into the firing line under the guise of his first round plan. It made gerrez look innocent which set him up to take on the role of the doctor.

At the time both Bodanki and RHC were set for the chop. It put gerrez in the firing line but gave a a 66.67% chance that one of Bodanki or RHC would be killed instead. If we assume they are both innocent then the chances are an innocent dies and gerrez is then set to assume his role within the townspeople. Risky move but the odds are with the mafia in this scenario.

Astro, gerrez, sky all mafia? Or two of the three?

 

Also who is our second investigator? Surely someone by this point has some good information that could make a real difference?

 

Fair enough, and as no one else has come forward to refute you're the doc I gave you the benefit of the doubt So far your story holds up as no evidence to say you aren't the Doc.

 

I think you have to consider other roles. I think it was clear that we wanted to protect Sky using the Doctor (this was before my announcement) after his claim, so the mafia wouldn't have gone for him as it was probably going to be a wasted night. By choosing Hash, it makes us question Sky.

However, what if Sky is the Mafia Investigator? Saying Hash was innocent before the Don killed him helps convince townies of Sky's innocence. I'm more inclined to lean this was now.

I also think the Mafia are sitting back and laughing at the developments. I've voted quite early in previous rounds. If all townies do this then the Mafia can see who we are going for. If the target is a townie, they don't need to do anything. So, I'm sitting back and waiting this time, hopefully other will do the same.

 

Hash was odd and maybe it was a personal attack by someone who he had accused. In that case afc could be an option like you say. Add in his erratic voting and switching last minute he's been very odd.

Like you I'm going to bank a vote with afcftw but as always will see what happens throughout the day and possibly change that later on.