OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

Seems a bit of a wierd time to come out with this, but ok.

 

Yes... and Sky said no role. So Sky got it right. If Sky is innocent- why did Mafia not try killing him? (since he has outed himself) ... or why not try killing someone else involved. Hash hasn't really implicated anyone, the only motive I can see to possibly off Hash is to make Sky look innocent. He's otherwise not a logical target.

Plus- there are pure-raw statistics. 4 out of 6 remaining roles are Mafia. 66.7% chance anyone with a role is mafia... Oh crap just realized I counted wrong there were 8 roles total at the start- 4 town 4 mafia... so 4/7 roles remaining not 4/6 are mafia... so only 57% chance he is Mafia... still... more than likely he is Mafia than town.

 

If I came out with it whilst under pressure than no one would believe me. I wanted to say in the last round but wasn't able to protect myself (can't protect same person two nights running). Saying it now gives us chance to look at some of these links posters keep suggesting.

 

How do we know Hash didn't have one of those roles ?

 

And I'm one of the town roles

 

MITO told us he was innocent

 

OK... so Gerrez says he is a Doctor. Does anyone else claim to be the doctor (remember you can protect yourself from a nightly hit if you are and come out... but not yourself and anyone claiming to be a cop).

 

Back to footy...

 

Fact he told us Magic was vigilante, would suggest he would have said if Hash had a role as well.

 

1) Why not kill Sky? Because as the only person who'd declared himself with a role (apart from Magic, who was blatantly going to cop it), then there was a good chance that the doctor would protect him, as was indeed the case (if we believe Greez), and that would have been a wasted move.

2) Maybe they were looking to frame Sky?

I'd probably have converted Hash rather than killed him if I were mafia though. He hasn't taken part much, so wouldn't have needed to do much to not act out of character, and would possibly have been under less suspicion having already been called innocent. Unless they thought we would doubt Sky once we found out that Magic was innocent. But still.

 

I'm suggesting: Sky, Bodanki, afcftw, Lucaaas

 

I would have converted you or Billy (if you're not Mafia) because you're active but keeping your rep clean- no one really suspects you. (besides AFC maybe).

 

I want to see who Sky says he investigated last night... AND see if anyone else makes a counter claim to Gerrez being the doctor.

 

I've got some lingering suspicion on Billy

 

I think RHC, Magic, Hash and MITO are the undead Mafia!

 

Billy is an odd one as he seems to have been quiet but he's actually been very active in this thread. Sees to have said a lot, without saying much.

Haven't really got anything to go on with him really...

 

Thanks ..... I missed that

 

Perfect mafia play?

I don't know, we all seem to be fairly blindly pointing at each other with no real idea while the mafia let us pick ourselves off (and give us a helping hand in doing so).

 

Yeah, I began to have doubts about Magic when there didn't seem to be any defense of him but figured stakes were great if he were guilty.

One Mafia hit will tell us a lot... gotta get one.

 

FFS you gimps, been saying it wasnt Magic since yesterday, just because he forgot to log in

3 innocents gone now, (and we lost our vigilante).

Cant believe you fell for Sky's BS about him having a "role", he has a role alright.