OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

I'd agree with most of that bar afc, he was online too

 

We only know two people who definitely have roles. Sky and Magic. We don't know if their roles are good or evil. Sky claims to be cop. Magic makes no claim as to what role he has.

Magic is probably going to be lynched today. If Magic turns out to be the doctor- then any investigator who comes out tonight will ultimately get killed some time during the night on one of the upcoming days (or converted).

It makes more sense for cops to stay quiet tonight. If we accidentally kill the doctor then they need to remain quiet until the Don is slain. If we kill the Don tonight then it makes sense for Cops to announce themselves tomorrow.

 

Sky, gerrez and milk together? I could see that.

 

How do we know who the first investigator is...?

 

As I said... admittedly it's very weak. Gerrez gave opinion he thought Sky was the vigilante without giving much explanation- and was quick to correct people on what they said about Sky. It's a weak link- and probably only reason I noticed it was because I had suspected both of them of guilt on day 1.

 

Thought we were working on assumption sky was? Or we not convinced...? I'm so confused

 

..... & what about the part you appear to have overlooked

 

How do we know this ?

Isn't this an assumption that they are both telling the truth ?

Milk .... your helpfulness seems very selective at times

This afternoon I have downloaded all the voting tables .... very interesting reading & shows different patterns when not bombarded with all the lies & counter-lies going on

 

We know because they both claimed to have roles. I have no idea if they are telling the truth- however, if they were townies- they would have no reason to lie. Claiming to have a role when being an innocent townie hurts their own team.

If they are Mafia- they would claim to have a role. If they are town-role players they might also claim to have a role. So because a regular townie would (hopefully) never say they have a role. Both Magic and Sky have roles.

There are 7 roles total. 4 of which are mafia. So 4/7 chance on each of them that they are Mafia.

 

Tell us more Minxy I only went for an hour and there's another 4 pages to read FFS

Love the way those who haven't played before are being dragged into this....simply because we haven't played before

 

Well, therein lies the problem, its an assumption. Some believe Sky to be mafia too. If he is be we go with the assumption then the mafia would be able to manipulate the situation to mislead us.

 

Who are Bodanki, milk and nozzer currently voting for?

 

I think the fact they've claimed to have roles suggests they do indeed have roles. The question is, do they have the role they claim or is it actually a mafia role?

 

I don't know why they changed their votes. Sky's original vote against me was "random" and Gerrez said I was being "too helpful and I reminded him of MITO last game".

If Sky & Gerrez were guilty- they may have not wanted to get caught both voting out the same person on day one. They could have decided to split up their vote.
If Sky & Gerrez were innocent- they probably changed their mind about who best to target.

 

If milk changes from magic prior to the voting then I think we have a mafia four of Bodanki, nozzer, milk and magic.

Bodanki, nozzer and milk voted for RHC when Bodanki looked obvious for the chop.

Bodanki and nozzer and now keeping Astro in the mix as he looks highly suspicious. Magic has had a lot of attention and milk is sticking with him for now, which would make magic look the obvious one for the chop, but should milk change prior to 8 then magic can be saved.

 

Why? Have you not checked your PM's

#joke

 

See both you and Gerrez are voting for Magic .... collusion or co-incidence ?

 

Magic is the don, Bodanki,nozzer and milk are mafia.

At least.... That's my latest theory...

 

I can tell you for sure that HASH is innocent.

I'm waiting on a PM to let you know some info on someone I suspect is the don. MITO where's my pm?? I've given you the name

 

You need to quote the full thing for it to be accurate though. I wasn't saying that as it appears, I said it was making me doubt myself because of the MITO thing last time.

Also, I've not voted for you