OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

So the basic status is:

Astro and afcftw both made late moves last night, making them look suspicious. People are trying to work out if they're foolish or dodgy. This then also conencts to Bodanki, who they appeared to be saving, and IBWT, who appears to be supporting Astro a bit.

Magic's lack of activity until he came under suspicion has some thinking he's the don.

Sky claim he has an important townie role and that Hash is innocent. Others suspect Sky.

Minxy, Hash, Gerrez, Milk, Lucaaas, Billy and myself don't appear to be under any particularly heavy suspicion at this point.

RHC is as dead as a culled badger.

 

I can assure you my actions have no bearing on whether Astro or Bodanki are a tally mafia or not... I made a call thinking Bodanki was innocent and we were about to make a mistake killing him and I was pretty sure RHC was mafia.... Got that totally wrong.

So don't read into my actions as proving or disproving anyone else's guilt!

 

Am I right in thinking I can only count thirteen there? There are fourteen of us left.


Edit: you missed Danilo

 

But lets not forget that IBWT spent all of the last game defending danilo despite him being innocent and danilo being the mafia don

 

I think billy is playing very clever and choosing when to say something to show he is around and egg others on but without directly getting involved in anything so as not to raise suspicion. Whether that is just his game plan or whether he is mafia I have no idea.

 

That's also his usual posting style

 

Oh I see...

I suppose it doesn't help that I'm not entirely sure what to expect from people so I may think certain things are suspicious when actually they are totally normal for that person.

 

If you changed your vote because you thought RHC was mafia and Bodanki was innocent why did you change to Sky FFS and leave RHC in a coinflip with Gerrez instead of voting for RHC anyway?

 

If myself, Bodanki and Astro are all innocent (which I'm starting to lean towards) then we are well and truly going in the wrong direction here...

 

r.i.p afcftw

 

#****

 

Shut up, don't put me on the mafia radar . Feels good not to have to worry about conversions and killings though. I would have gotten away with it too if it weren't for you meddling kids.

Speaking on previous experience, not converting the first night cost me badly, so I would not make that mistake again. Especially not in the second night, where I was unable to convert anyone either Gerrez being killed off prematurely. If something like that happens again, it's a first time player, someone who didn't get involved much last round, or a new player who wasn't in round 1.

For the moment I'm banking Milk as my vote because I think he's pulling a MITO and pretending to give helpful, objective posts. Although if a mafia slips up I'll definitely change, even last minute if need be.

 

I changed to sky because I thought he was hiding something (which everyone else seems to agree with now), I said I was going to change my vote and asked others if they would of the same and then changed my vote. Granted it all happened rather quickly but time was ticking down and Bodanki convinced me he was innocent.

RHC I was pretty sure was guilty (woops) but I didn't think he was the don and figured it was worth throwing sky into the mix as well if I could.

By changing my vote RHC stayed on the chopping block regardless. But by voting for him I would of guaranteed he went. All I was feeling certain on was bodanki a innocence. Which I then felt incredibly stupid about when you changed your vote which implicated Bodanki.

 

Have just read through all the posts since I went out last night & am as confused as before ..... although I am beginning to build a picture of who I don't trust

The only thing I feel certain about is who is still alive

 

And my vote had nothing to do with gerrez... Your thee one who dragged him into a chance of elimination..

 

But there was no way of getting Sky into the coinflip so late anyway. I left my vote so late because I wanted it to be last and get 3 in the coinflip rather than 2. My vote DIDN'T implicate Bodanki except by making him less likely to die, which is what you wanted anyway!

That said, I'm still open to you being ******ed rather than mafia

 

At this point, I've decided that I am innocent and every single one of you is Mafia scum!



Milk - Only known innocent... by me

Nozzer - Nozzer has kept his nose clean all game and not said or done anything controversial. He does tend to help keep coin toss alive, and has been consistent in that approach. For example. RHC/Bodanki. If Bodanki ended up innocent- that would be a good Mafia tactic (doesn't mean he would be Mafia) because he would know both are innocent. Not flagging Nozzer as suspicious yet. Nozzer cast a vote for "innocent RHC" (so did I though)

Minxy - Minxy hasn't been very active and I think she cast a singleton vote in day 1 (would have to go back and check) - both could be considered suspicious- but not a smoking gun.

Danilo _ Danilo- see Minxy. Not very active and cast a singleton vote.

afcftw - either guilty or erratic. AFCFTW has been jumping all over the place it makes it hard to tell if guilty or not. As of right now- I'm not convinced of innocence.

hash - very quiet. Hasn't said much. If sky is innocent the Hash is too. If sky isn't then we don't know about Hash. Hash placed 2nd vote on Gerrez (putting him in slightly dangerous territory). I think if Gerrez is Mafia then Hash probably isn't. Hash/Gerrez are not likely to both be mafia.

lucaas - very quiet which can be suspicious but voting didn't seem suspicious.

ibwt - the only thing I have on IBWT is that he seems to be keen on defending Astro. If Astro ends up guilty- this doesn't mean IBWT is too- but it might. If Astro is innocent I think this means IBWT probably is too because I can't see Mafia defending an innocent who looks fairly certain to be killed.

billy can - Billy Can has run a fairly clean game. I hope to goodness he isn't Mafia.

gerrez I've not given up on Gerrez's guilt. If Astro ends up guilty then Gerrez most likely isn't. If Astro ends up innocent then Gerrez is still a leading suspect. I can't remember why- but at one point I thought there was some link up between Gerrez and Sky- I'll have to look back later and see why I thought that. Gerrez has been keen on targeting Magic- we know Magic has a role. If Magic ends up guilty that would remove some suspicion from Gerrez (And indeed everyone who put votes on Magic early). If Magic ends innocent (especially if Astro is too) - then that would make me suspect Gerrez more.

magic Magic is either town role or Mafia Don... . I'm keeping my vote on him. If he's Mafia Don it a big victory for the town on day 2.

bodanki I thought Bodanki was innocent part of yesterday because he was out ahead and no one was protecting him. But then the last minute shenanigans of Day 1 changed it completely. AFC and Astro changed it from a coin toss between Bod and RHC to a coin toss between Gerrez and RHC- together they took Bod completely out of the equation. This puts huge suspicion of an AFC-Astro-Bod triumvirate. If any one of that threesome ends up guilty it means the other two should be investigated more closely. AFC just may be a strange wildcard in all this- but if Astro or Bod are innocent the other might be too... and vice versa. We know Bod has cast one vote against an innocent (RHC - as have I and Nozzer)


Sky Sky may or may not be telling the truth. 4/7 chance he's the Mafia. As I said under Gerrez- can't recall why, but I had a feeling that he and Sky may be linked. If one is guilty the other might be too. There were times yesterday I suspected Sky. Lack of voting- waiting to vote despite being online- and then casting a vote that put someone in danger.

Astro Astro... Astro... Astro... Either guilty as sin (in which case we need to look at Bod, IBWT, and AFC). It is interesting to note though that Bodanki AND AFC immediately cast votes for Astro. Unless they change(d) those votes then that tends to make the case for Astro weaker. Since Bod (and maybe RHC who was innocent) had the most to gain from Astro's move it seems strange they would jump on him if he in cahoots with them.

In fact the first four people to jump on Astro were:
Nozzer, Gerrez, Bod and AFC.

If Astro ends up innocent- we need to look at those potential "opportunists".






So... in otherwords- I have no clue who is guilty and who is not- but I think we've got to a point in the game now that we have a lot of clues based on the guilt/innocence of who dies tonight.

 

In the five minutes leading up to nightfall I expressed my feelings that we had got it wrong, that Bodanki was innocent and that sky was mafia. I took the risk to save Bodanki who I believed innocent and threw the idea out there that sky was guilty.

Given that our two votes changed the outcome I don't think you can say it was too late to get someone in hot water.

I took a roll of the dice hoping someone else had seen what I had and would go with me. They didn't. (Didn't help that by the time I actually got my vote changed it was dead on deadline).

If that equates to me being ******ed, then I'm ******ed. Either way I'm not mafia.

 

I voted for Astro but switched to sky... Should Astro fall out of the limelight I'm likely to switch my vote back to him.

It looks likely to be a combo of me, Bodanki and Astro.

Or IBWT, hash and Astro.

Definitely some sort of links have seemed present between those people. As I said earlier the links between people can easily be misguided and cast suspicion on the totally wrong people so I have no confidence in this

However, knowing I'm innocent I have to say keep an eye on IBWT, hash and Astro and see if you can see any correlation between them. At least two of them have voted for the same person on more than one occasion I think?

 

Not me.