OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

But the voting meant gerrez was up for the chop. Pretty sure he isn't mafia.

 

Yes per other post it would be announced as the doctor happened across x or y in a bloody pool and saved them

I would not reveal x or ys role and so the doctor could save a mafia or an innocent, cos they are a doctor. They save lives

 

That's what the mafia would say...

 

No. I mean this is their first game. It would rule out those who played Mafia1 too... so only rules out half the people.

 

If Astro's innocent it tells us he's a plonker for acting so suspiciously and leading us on a merry goose chase.

 

I would agree it is extremely unlikely both Gerrez and Astro are Mafia. If Astro turns up innocent then Gerrez would be suspicious again. If Astro is guilty- Gerrez is almost certainly innocent.

 

Have they though?

 

That's some twisted bollox right there lol

Astro is clearly Mafia, as is afcftw too. They saved your arse!

I clearly said RHC was innocent, why do that if I'm Mafia?

I was believing you to be innocent but that accusation just put you right back in the dock for me.

At this moment, I'm thinking Astro, Bod, afcftw & magic are Mafia!

 

This is blatantly not your first game. Hence the point rules you out.

 

As clearly as DR was last game?

 

Double bluff

At this moment I'm with you on those names.. Magic or Bondanki being prime candidates for the don.

 

Astro was putting me in the firing line no matter what AFC did. I think Bod as just ****ed up

 

I reckon it's Greez and IBWT.

 

Yup true, but Astro thought it was a 1 in 3 vote, AFC made it 1 in 2 by changing

Astro looks very suspicious but keep referring back to his original statement of "if 1 vote per person isn't going ahead I'll change to make it a tie if I can"

He's been consistant in that approach. Also he's been consistant in his approach from last game as well which he was innocent in...

Game is so bloody confusing

 

I reckon it was the German...

 

I never claimed DR was 'clearly Mafia'.

I know I'm innocent. Astro and AFC just voted in the dying second to save Bod. No Don action points at magic.

 

I understand why people are going to think I might be mafia now so I don't mind the votes! But I can assure you I just took a gamble thinking Bodanki was innocent, RHC probably was mafia and that skylarker had been missed.

If we assume for a minute that I'm telling the truth and my vote wasn't intended as a mafia save, but rather trying to save a towns person. Then that means Astro had no idea I was going to do what I did. So let's look at his vote on its own:

Bodanki and RHC where going to go to a coin toss. Astros vote would have made it three ways with gerrez.

Lots of us seem to think gerrez has a role, so maybe The mafia figured rather than save Bodanki (which would mean he isn't the don but a normal mafia member) why not get gerrez in on the coin toss? That way the odds where 1/3 that they lost a member, 2/3 they kill a towns person and possibly a towns person with an additional role?

Would mean both Astro and Bodanki are mafia.

 

Maybe, but it as already a tie. And have the tie is designed to make the mafia react; they can't do that when the switch is so late. And why bring in so much suspicion on yourself? And why then not answer and explain yourself?

 

Saving Bodanki las tminute would put him as a Don in my eyes as well, although Magic is ahead on that front.

I'd say 70% Magic, 30% Bod.

 

You might be right. Astro didn't need to vote for me, AFC changing saved Bod on it's own.

Where or investigator with info? Or did they not find anything worthwhile?