OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

Either way I am probably ****ed for the next round, between me putting the house on RHC's guilt and my last minute "bail out" by Afcftw, I may as well commit Seppuku.

 

Batard! You found me out!

 

Yes I would say that the doctor happened on a bloody scene and saved whomever he saved. This would allow the dr to not have to reveal all

 

If your mafia I've just saved you and put myself in the firing line possibly saving you another day... Your a lying bastard if your not a towns person!

 

Well, so far Astro's leading the way, so there may be hope for you yet.

 

The more I think about it the more I'm thinking I've been taken for a fool and Bodanki is mafia...

 

This hurts my head.

 

So 4 possible reasons no conversion or kill last night.


1) They tried to convert/kill RHC. Unlikely unless the Don picked RHC and hasn't been on for a while. RHC had been a candidate for lynching early on.

2) The Don/Mafia didn't understand what they had to do. Would implicate the Don as being someone new to the game- which is about half the people on here.

3) The Don/Mafia never logged in to post a suggestion. That would paint Magic as the Don.

4) They are waiting being strategic to use the conversion. I don't think this is a wise decision- especially since ultimately Mafia lost last game from being always unable to convert.


If Astro and/or AFC are innocent- they've hurt the town's chance of winning. If they're guilty, we're golden.

 

One of my first posts after 8 was to apologise and say I've probably just ****ed day two

 

Only if whoever gets voted off is Mafia. (and that person is AFC or Astro) - if either turn out to be townsperson you might be safe.

 

I'm a towns person but don't let that absolve Bodanki!

 

Fair enough but would it be announced?

Edit... Ignore this

 

Me, you and Bodanki lynched RHC. I think we can rule out 1).

 

Classic mafia protests.

 

Maybe you three are the mafia

 

So lets think logically, for me, the only people I know for sure were innocent were me and RHC.
The last minute changes MUST have been to save someone, and as the Mafia know for sure I am not mafia, I can only conclude that the changes were made to eliminate the possibilty of the 3 way tie.
Since myself and RHC are towns folk, i can only conclude that Greez is mafia!!

 

Is this whole post designed to point us away from the fact that you're the don?

 

Since it is your first game I tend to think you're more likely innocent than Astro. tbh...

However, as I've said since the beginning, I think a one horse race is never good for the town. Therefore I'm voting for AFCFTW to try and make it a two horse race.
(if AFC pulls ahead of Astro- I will probably change my vote to Astro because I think he is more likely guilty).


What their deaths will tell us:
Astro - if Mafia (Bodanki is also very likely Mafia)
- if Innocent (tells us absolutely nothing).

Bodanki - If Mafia (would lend suspicion to Astro and AFC)
- if innocent (again, unfortunately would tell us very little... would probably have to go back to early day one and see who was voting for you early on).

AFC - If Mafia (would lend suspicion to Bodanki)
- if innocent (again, this tells us almost nothing... would have to go back to early day one and see who you were voting for).



Unfortuantely, of the 3 main suspects- their deaths only help narrow down choices if they are Mafia. If they're innocent we learn nothing new. (and should probably look at people who voted singleton votes)

 

We already know that I'm innocent. Milk says he's innocent too. Bodanki's a possibility.

 

If Gerrez is Mafia, then Astro can't be as his vote would have put Gerrez in the firing line (as he didn't know afc was changing last minute as well)??