OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

MITO...

Would u tell us if the doctor saved anyone?

 

I've suspected Sky too- but not convinced... I think he would be a good one to investigate since he is quiet and unlikely to give himself away. Don't think we should vote for him today.

It was bizarre- but I would believe that AFCFTW is less likely to know he'd put himself on the chopping block for that than Astro. I had thought previously that Bodanki was innocent too.

I would agree with that logic. And Magic becomes much more suspicious all of a sudden. It's either Magic or someone who this is their first time playing. I have difficulty believing anyone who was in the last game would let the opportunity to do an early conversion would let the opportunity slip again after what happened last time.

 

Magic not being around is suspicious of the don if nothing was done I guess. Bodanki wasn't on too much and then got saved last minute by Afc. Very risky leaving it that late if Bodanki is the don but could be a very good tactic I guess? Minxy wasn't around much as was Sky...

Trying to think who else is playing that's not been around?

 

I think Astro and sky should be the two up for the chop and I'd be investigating nozzer or milk if I could...

 

Unless the Don tried to convert but the doctor saved the townie. Waiting for MITO to announce whether this would be revealed or not

 

My move has made myself and Bodanki look really suspicious, but I'm not mafia and I don't think Bodanki is and I reckon I might of just ****ed day two

 

Sacrifice the pawn to save the king? That would indicate Bodanki to me, as otherwise I see no reason for Astro to bring attention to himself.

 

I'm sorry to all the townspeople who are going to waste time now suspecting me! And I bet the mafia are having a right laugh...

 

The only thing that bothers me about Astro is who was he trying to save? Bodanki?

It wasn't RHC, RHC was innocent.

I could see why they'd want Gerrez out- they probably suspect Gerrez has a town role. If Astro is guilty, Bodanki is probably guilty. If Bodanki is guilty then AFC is probably guilty. Would Bodanki and AFC have been playing each other trying to distance themselves early on?


If for some reason Astro turns up innocent after tonight (assuming he's axed) what does that tell us? Unfortunately very little. As that would take some of the burden from Bod and AFC (although not completely).

 

I hope your not right

 

See my comment above about the doctor before reading too much into this thought pattern

 

I'm innocent.

 

In which case the doctor knows 2 people who are probably innocent. THEMSELVES and the person they were protecting. (unless they were protecting themselves).

 

Oh and for the record Nozzer posted reply 666 so should be considered suspicious because of that.

 

I'm waiting for MITOs response

 

I wish we could investigate Bodanki before tonight. Because if Bod is innocent then Astro and AFC would be let off the hook a little and we could look elsewhere. If Bodanki IS Mafia, he's probably high ranking Mafia or why would AFC and Astro do something so risky last minute.

 

The explanation of Astro jumping in to save Bodanki is cracking me up thinking I just accidentally saved the don. Getting funny looks

 

As I said befor, maybe Astro was trying to save Bodanki. Afcftw hadn't changed to Sky at that point, so maybe Astro went with coin flip to give him more of a chance, but being slightly less obvious than voting for RHC to guarantee Bodanki's safety. I think we're basiclly waiting for Astro to explain his actions!

 

A doctor would not save someone from conversion. There is no medical need. A doctor comes along and finds someone with a bullet in his back and saves them... They happen along on their hunch and is intended to balance the mafias ability to assassinate

This is the same reason why the vigilante is balanced by the goon, just to try and balance powers

 

Agree on Astro. Looks very dodgy.

The only thing that edges AFC ahead of him at the moment for me, is Astro did say if his 1 vote per person thing wasn't going to plan he would change at the end to try and make it a tie and toss of the coin, which had AFC not changed, his vote would have made it 3 for Bodanki, RHC & Gerrez.

Still suspicious but I can see some sort of logic in that?