I like the multiple mafia approach. Not too many on one team to take over and dominate too quickly but also not too many townies which keeps it a bit more interesting for the norms because there is a higher success rate.
No **** PS...you need to re-read the first couple of pages of this thread. I didn't know the rules either so I asked lots of questions
Oh... one rule that fortunately didn't need to get mentioned- but we probably want it on the first page next time round... You can't use PMs from the host (or screenshots of them) as evidence for being innocent. / I've never seen people try to do this- but I've seen people post that rule so some people may try to do that!
I don't understand what you mean Do you mean a towny investigator posting a screenshot to prove they've found a mafia member?
I assume he means e.g. you or Astro posting a screenshot of your PM from Milk with your role to prove that you're innocent and save yourselves from being killed.
Yes, to both of those... it would be against the spirit of the game to post that kind of thing. Not that anyone here would try it- but probably need to include that rule in the header of game 2.
We didn't get a PM from Milk to say we were innocent. The only ones that got a PM were the ones that had a role to play so as mafia or Town Investigators, I suppose the latter could use the PM but they'd be outing themselves to the mafia too.
The only thing that concerns me about the game is the PM system. There is no way of stopping or knowing if people are cheating bar people snitching (so don't PM MITO ).
For that matter... I think some people on here know other peoples' facebook accounts or email addresses, phone numbers, etc... people could cheat by communicating privately... have to just trust everyone.
