Morning all. sky you can vote any time. The closure for votes is tomorrow, which probably for next time is too long a time. anyway... i digress. i said yesterday I'd leave it til today. Here is what I can sum it up as: Facts: 1. Astro was innocent 2. Gerrez was innocent 3. Mafia have not used their convert or kill. 4. There are 2 mafia and 6 townspeople with 2 investigators in the game. Statements made: 1. Lucaas claims to be town investigator and danilo is mafia don and that dr is town investigator. 2. Danilo claims to be town investigator and Sky is innocent. I don't think he has offered a new person he investigated? 3. Dr admitted to be town investigator and sky is innocent (my fault for outing him) I THINK he is saying IBWT is innocent too. My view: 1. Round 1: I thought that it was a bid mad personally and astro went full on which is prob why he got done in. I didn't see much hard evidence of anything 2. Round 2: when Lucaas said right off he was the town investigator and danilo was the don certainly I thought it was convincing and so I did vote for Danilo. I said the round was all about danilo v lucaas and I did the same thing in weighing the evidence and trying to find the best choice. However I think being a weekend as well I prob voted before others came on and offered up more info. Danilo came on and claimed he was town investigator and offered that sky was innocent. Then dr changed his vote to lucaas. Then Lucaas claimed dr is mafia and I change my vote. I thought i even caught Lucaas out in a mistake over which role he said danilo had. Then somehow in the middle of all that luv and hash voted for gerrez..... We had a 3 way tie and geerez got picked 3. Round 3: Lucaas has his cards on the table now. The other 2 I think need to be clear what is the story? I certainly got confused last night when dr said he wasn't an investigator after the result but since then he admitted he was. I am also really wondering why the hell luv and hash voted for gerrez cos I thought it was patently obvious he was innocent! you know with gerrez if he wanted to be mafia at the start and wasn't. thats my view anyway. Are luv and hash just ripping the piss? I don't know it was the weeked for all i know they just voted the way they voted and thats just that. Yesterday I felt strongly enough that lucaas was trying to finger danilo and did so carrying on the prior rounds accusations. there are 3 people saying they are for 2 roles. Now unless someone else is laying low then 2 of the 3 are truthful and one is lying. I think everyone is in agreement with that. There are two or even 3 hypotheses now: 1. Lucas is truthful and danilo is lying and the don. If so why was no mafia tool used. Milk first said there was then retracted. what was that about? surely danilo would have used some tool even if to simply kill one of the other two? If danilo is the don how does the information given fit in? why did dr and danilo say the same person? however now lucaas says dr IS a town investigator. that means he would be telling the truth so how would that work. did danilo and dr investigate sky at the same time (1 in say 8 shot each given ibwt and astro were tied 4/4) did danilo simply just pick somone at random and get lucky? 2. Lucas and Dr are lying and danilo is innocent If Lucaas is a mafia then Dr would have to be too and the lie this round is Dr being town investigator. I don't find this one plausible as Lucaas had it all wrapped up before dr turned up and contradicted it. It would also put both mafia at risk and no tools were used either. it'd just be mad. The only possible thing i can think is if they knew danilo was going to be found innocent then lucaas was going out but I can't see it as when it occurred I certainly didn't expect gerrez to attract 2 votes from nowhere 3. Dr and Danilo are truthful and lucaas is lying If so again why was no mafia tool used? would dr not get killed or converted. Again why would both investigators go for sky? (again as above 1 in say 8 shot each given ibwt and astro were tied 4/4) If danilo is telling the truth why not offer another name of who was investigated yet? I think Dr might have alluded to IBWT being innocent but I am reading into a comment not reading a straight out statement. So here are some questions: 1. Lucaas, you are being specific about two people. Danilo is the don and Dr is an town investigator. This leaves the post you made accusing me of being mafia also. Is this cos i switched votes or is it cos I caught you out? Is it just supposition? 2. Dr are you saying IBWT is innocent? 3. Danilo you have only said one name so far. Lucaas has offered two names, can you offer another? 4. Luv and hash, Can you give reasons as to votes for gerrez? I would like to hear as much as I can. Yesterday I said i was 7% percent sure then voted Danilo, today I think I am 90% sure its lucaas but want to wait and see cos there's two days voting to go.
oh and above i read 7% that was 75% and a typo... i was 75% sure that danilo was the don per lucaas and even waited while watching f1 then voted.
You want to double kill Gerrez? Danilo.(3 votes) ; Lucaaas, IBWT, Sky DR(1 votes); Hash Lucaaas(1 vote) ; DR Not Yet Voted: Danilo, Mito, Gonzo
Check your Notification in boxes... if it is full please delete a few messages! So that I can PM you Thank you
Holy **** - that's deep. I'm still not even sure how this game works - I just read the PM's I keep getting and vote <whsitle> I thought it was that simple, obviously not.
Is that a vote for Danilo? Or just considering Danilo? (not bolded) - I will count it as a vote if I don't see any other response from you before night fall.
since you died this has gone down hill... I vote Lucaas by the by. nobody's bothered to post anything today in reply to my summation bar sky and luv just voted and didn't answer question so i think we need to shorten the time frame on next game.
milk hears dead people too.. i wonder if its catching. even though you didn't agree at least we played it right IMO. fun game.
i'm a medium, like the ghost whisperer... I considered talking to astro when his spooky voice appeared but i was afraid he'd possess me and make me go medieval on IBWT. Is there anyone you need to talk to or kill before you walk into the light...............
Dead people shouldn't be influencing the vote! Danilo.(4?votes) ; Lucaaas, IBWT, Sky, Gonzo? Lucaaas(2 votes) ; DR, Mito DR(1 votes); Hash Not Yet Voted: Danilo
Thats obviously aimed at me for some reason but I don't know why, I've not said anything! I just responded to MITO
