Kanu for West Brom from 2 yards vs Middlesborough in 2005/06 I remember reading in the newspaper that one guy had placed an accumulator bet on all 10 PL fixtures that weekend. WBA vs Boro was the last match of the weekend and, after getting every other result spot on, he needed the game to end in a draw to win roughly £10,000. With 2 mins to go Kanu missed from two yards with Boro 2-1 up
How about Andy Cole vs West Ham last game of the season 1995. Andy Cole had the championship at his feet...until he fell over them.