Player Ratings - For the Season

Mine are:

Harper: 8
Collo: 9
Enrique: 8
Nolan:9
Campbell: 3
Williamson: 6
Barton: 10
Guthrie: 6
Lovenkrands: 6
Simpson: 6
Perch: 2
Gutierrez: 7
Best: 7
Ameobi: 6
Tiote: 9 (would be 10 but too many silly bookings)
Krul: 7
S. Taylor: 7
Ranger: 5
Ferguson: 7
Kuqi: 11

 

Was going to do my own but yours are spot on IMO, would have Barton as 9 though, there's been a couple of **** games for him and he did punch Pederson. Also maybe S Taylor a 6, he's only played about 6 or 7 games.

 

What did Perch do well that merits getting a 2?!

 

You don't deserve an answer, peasant.

Harper: 7
Collo: 8
Enrique: 8
Nolan:8
Campbell: 3
Williamson: 7
Barton: 9
Guthrie: 6 (Would be a lot higher if he wasn't injured for the majority of the season)
Lovenkrands: 7
Simpson: 7
Perch: 1
Gutierrez: 7
Best: 8
Ameobi: 5 1/2
Tiote: 9
Krul: 8
S. Taylor: 6 1/2
Ranger: 5
Ferguson: 8
Kuqi: <3

 

Harper: 7
Coloccini: 9
Enrique: 8
Nolan: 8
Campbell: 5
Williamson: 7
Barton: 8
Guthrie: 6
Lovenkrands: 7
Simpson: 7
Perch: 3
Gutierrez: 8
Best: 7
Ameobi: 7
Tiote: 9
Krul: 8
S. Taylor: 9
Ranger: 5
Ferguson: 8
Kuqi: 100

 

I think we're forgetting Ben Arfa

If we're including Kuqi/Steven Taylor/Sol Campbell, may as well include Ben Arfa

 

Blimey Campbell is getting decent score id give him 1

 

pretty much this

 

Glad to see most have put Krul higher than Harper, he's played more games than him this season and i think he is generally better!

Harper: 7
Krul: 8
Simpson: 7
Perch: 4
Saylor: 7
Williamson: 5
Colo: 8
Campbellend: 2
Enrique: 7
Raylor: 5
Barton: 9
Routledge: 5
Jonas: 7
Ferguson: 7
Ben Arfa: 5
Guthrie: 6
Tiote: 8
Nolan: 8
Smith: 4
Kuqi: Hmmm.
Ameobi: 4
Loven: 6
Best: 7
Ranger: 4
Ireland: 2
Carroll: 8

 

Are the ratings supposed to be just for the games they've played, or their overall impact on our season?

 

I've gone for impact compared to what we hoped i suppose. Bit of each.

 

Agree with you Tiotesleftfoot, probably give Ranger a 6 or something though. I know he's not scored but he has been a brilliant impact sub and has changed games.

Can we keep Kuqi? I'm going to miss him!!

MOTD on now. Looks set to be epic

 

Harper 8
Krul 7 - Still learning the game, will be class in 2-3 years time.
Simmo - 7 Some great games, but some dire defending - Tottenham and Today
Perch - 1.1
Collo - 8
Willo - 7 Done a decent job in that only three seasons ago, he was playing for Wycombe
Jose - 7
Saylor - 7
Barton -9
Nolan - 9 ( him + ^ are the driving force in our team.
Guthrie - 7 very good late on in season
Jonas - 8
Smith - 5 he had 1 good game
Campbell - 0 the two games I've been to, he has played and ruined the match
Fergie - 7 great prospect
LuaLua - 6 good for Brighton and looks good for us
Ireland - 5 was bright in te games fo us, but not enough games tbf
AC - 8 before he left :/
Lover - 7
Shola -5
Ranger - 5.5 had by far the miss of the season
Kuqi - 5
Best - 7.5 looked a class striker at times.

Who else?

 

Harper 8
Krul 7 - Still learning the game, will be class in 2-3 years time.
Simmo - 7 Some great games, but some dire defending - Tottenham and Today
Perch - 1.1
Collo - 8
Willo - 7 Done a decent job in that only three seasons ago, he was playing for Wycombe
Jose - 7
Saylor - 7
Barton -9
Nolan - 9 ( him + ^ are the driving force in our team.
Guthrie - 7 very good late on in season
Jonas - 8
Smith - 5 he had 1 good game
Campbell - 0 the two games I've been to, he has played and ruined the match
Fergie - 7 great prospect
LuaLua - 6 good for Brighton and looks good for us
Ireland - 5 was bright in te games fo us, but not enough games tbf
AC - 8 before he left :/
Lover - 7
Shola -5
Ranger - 5.5 had by far the miss of the season
Kuqi - 5
Best - 7.5 looked a class striker at times.
Tiote - 10
Ben Arfa - 6.5 in the glimpse he gave us
Raylor - 6 played alrite for us.

Who else?

 

Too generous, but I am a born cynic.

Harper: 6
Collo: 9
Enrique: 8
Nolan:9
Campbell: 3
Williamson: 6
Barton: 8
Guthrie: 6
Lovenkrands: 6
Simpson: 6
Perch: 2
Gutierrez: 6
Best: 6
Ameobi: 5
Tiote: 7
Krul: 6
S. Taylor: 6
Ranger: 3
Ferguson: 8

Colo player of the season without a doubt. Hope he gets it but can see Jose gettin the vote.

 

I'd say Ben Arfa was a 9 in the glimpse he gave! But injury and setbacks lower his rating for me.

And yeah i noticed you left somebody out of the first one! What would Cheik say

 

I'd say harsh on Krul, Simpson, Jonas and Saylor! Possibly Ranger comparing him to Campbell! Also Tiote got our player of the season?

 

Harper 7
Krul 7
Simpson 5
Williamson 7
Coloccini 9
Enrique 8
Barton 8
Nolan 7
Tiote 8
Gutierrez 7
Ameobi 4
Lovenkrands 4
Best 7

Mine are for the main guys who played.

 

Krul was no better than Harps, just average. Simpson and Jonas were just that, average. Saylor has done well since he come back but he's struggled to displace Williamson, that says it all. Ranger has been bollocks every game I've seen him in other than bin dippers at home. Didn't know our player of the season had been announced yet, thought Jose would've got it but Tiote winning was no surprise really, despite 14 bookings and match losing mistakes....it seems most of our lot believe hype instead of actually watching games.

 

Think a lot of that post is spot on mate!

However i think Krul egded Harps this season and played more games.
Simpson has been average/good but not great.
Jonas has played 37 games and gives us something not one other player in our team can, the ability to run at players and keep the ball. I'd rather he ran up the field with the ball and held it up than hoofing it to Shola to hold up.
Saylor hasn't had the chances and when he's played at CB he's been our best CB. One shoddy game at RB got him dropped but he's come back in and shown why we all loved him.
Ranger hasn't been good, but been better than Campbell! Ranger isn't fulfilling his potential and next year has to be his year or he is Shola II.
Tiote has had countless stupid bookings. Too many mistakes but has been a bargain and hopefully can only improve.
Jose has been ****e for a quarter of the season and for all i care can go. He is terrific on his day but still is sloppy and makes mistakes. One thing i notice is if a player is running at him with pace he tends to do well but if players are playing it around him or taking their time he falls asleep. And what was he doing with his marking for the 3rd goal today! Just walked away from his man!