Attitude to Gratitude

So it doesn't say in Sahih Muslim and Sahih al-Bukhari that she was married at 6, then?
Another bit of pick-and-choose theism?

 

And it still continues to this day among Muslims:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-17534262

 

You two want to be careful - you'll be accused of being hypocrites for reading and then commenting about something that you don't believe in. I'm sure that would really ruin your respective days

 

really? ok mr google and wikki king. find the references that are quoted in Bukhari/muslim and read the daleel

whilst at it read what Ibn saad said in the tabaqat

hen read what aisha herself said about her age and when certain surahs/ayah were revealed

then read Ibn Kathir

once you have done this, then you will see the age

Problem with people like you is that nt only do you have very little knowledge, but also you dont understand how things like hadith work.
and this is why your proclamations about your own faith (or lack of) are rubbish IMO. Basically as its not an informed decision

Its a judgement pre made, then held onto by the thinnest of threads. The main method being to focus on something that is a 'negative' (but oftne not even true as in the case of Aisha) which you attempt to use as a stick

keep trying though. only Jews and christians allowed marriages to children. Islam changed that

 

I shouldnt, but I will

where does it say she was muslim?

she may have been Jewish/christian.

we dont know as they didnt reveal the girls details. But dont let that stop you eh

 

Aye, because Pakistan is full of Jews and Christians synonymous with arranged marriages.

Just keep proving how stupid you are Fan

 

thick **** it doesnt say she was pakistani. If anything it appears to be iranian/kurdish

Funnily enough, this is the educating bit, in pakistan jews and christians get married young. It becomes a cultural thing like naming your kid yusuf instead of joseph etc

In fact the pakistani (muslims in this case) often do the whole 'arranged' marriage thing due to Indian/Hindu culture simply due to history. In fact many of the customs displayed at 'muslim' weddings today in the UK have their roots in Indian/hindu culture than Islam.

 

I thought you were in Carmarthen?

More lies from the simpleton

 

As I said, just carry on proving how stupid you are. Calling me a thick **** degrades you more than it does me.

Let's look at the facts:

- The author is called Poonam Taneja, an expert in forced marriages in Asia, particularly India, Pakistan and Bangladesh
- She is BBC Asia correspondent
- The article includes a story about a 13 year old girl being abducted, flown to Pakistan and forced to marry a man twice her age
- The 13 year old girl's name is Sameem Ali, a muslim
- Pakistani muslims are well known for forcing young girls into forced marriages

You cannot win this argument Fan. You don't have the intelligence as has become evident with your inability to spell a word that's someone else (me) used to describe you, your inability to google said word properly and not even being able to send a PM despite claiming to have been an IT teacher. Plus a whole list of other examples of utter stupidity you've displayed on here over the last few months.

I'm not arguing with you. I'm merely pointing out facts. As I said to Jip yesterday, you have obvious mental problems and engaging you in any sort of debate will not help you.

I really do hope you get help overcoming your mental problems and that at some future point you are able to discuss subjects honestly and intelligently.

 

only went to pick some thing up

got back in the early hours, was home for around 2 am ish

 

One of your 500 kids you had left behind in the bar while you scored crack?

 

the bit you cut and pasted was about a 5 year old

backtrack, backtrack

since we are looking at things historically how do I find your dumb and dumber quote?

as I said thick ****

 

a bain marie and a gridle

TBH having 500 kids whilst on crack would be an achievement, wouldnt it? Even I would 'doff my cap' at that dude

 

Woohoo, the I.T teacher understands cut and paste!

<GOOGLEFAIL>

 

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...anguish-forced-marriage-age-5--living-UK.html

I shall add no further comment.

 

understanding it is one thing, its the doing it bit i struggled with

git

 

If someone claimed that they are clearly winning an argument because the other person resorts to insulting them, would their engagement in exactly the same thing mean that they've conceded defeat? Or would it just mean that they were a hypocrite?

 

that wasnt your original article, but never mind

its really sad what happened to this lass but if you read the article further she wasnt married at 5

'Samina was still a frightened girl of 14 when she went through the formal wedding ceremony which marked her transition from her parents' house to that of her husband'

As I said before some of the ''traditions' that occur in pakistani households are not 'Islamic' and are cultural.

These stories are indeed sad and shouldnt happen, however you cannot pin them on religion.
The rape of boys by priests occurs but it isnt christian

 

I see what you are getting at. however if you recall there was also a bit about 'responding in kind'.

small print, should always read it