Steven Taylor or Mike Williamson to start against Wolves?

Vote!

I would go for Taylor to be honest. Williamson hasn't really impressed me and Taylor should get his chance since the whole back 4/5 have been pretty poor lately.

 

Taylor. Quicker than Willo, makes less mistakes (he always looks like he's going to but seems to get the job done) and better distribution.

My main gripe with Williamson is how much pressure he puts the team under by not being able to find a team mate. Too often he slices his clearances out for a throw in in our defensive half. He occasionally shanks them straight to an opposition player as well. Taylor's decision making is good, he knows when he can play it short into midfield and he knows when to put his foot through it. He's also comfortable on the ball and able to carry it out of defence himself.

 

Went for Saylor. Although I dont hate Willo as much as many on here, hes decent enough for us IMO, especially if hes just backup for Saylor. Saylor & Willo as a cb pairing would worry me though if Colo was out.

 

I like Williamson, but he's struggled the last couple of games, so thinks its time to give Taylor a run.

 

I agree with everyone here. Willo hasn't been his best lately, and the defence has been shaky, so it's time to give Taylor a go.

 

Steven Taylor but only if he is 100% fit.
I don't hate Williamson, I just dont rate him that much and would only keep him in summer if he was prepared to be 4th choice.

 

If Saylor comes back in he should earn his place in training and make Pards pick him. I don't have a problem if he does cone in but I don't want to see Willo dropped for a couple of poor performances when he's had a spectacular season compared to what I expected of him.

 

This.

 

Taylor I went for, people.

 

This thread reminds me of the Williamson or Taylor thread

 

Yeah thought that, and who started that article?

 

It got taken down though before many people could comment on the real issue. Lets not stray off topic again please.

 

Sorry, didn't know that, I have already said Taylor and voted for him.

 

Williamson, because Taylor is awful. Cant be arsed to go into detail again but thats my opinion.

 

This...also the last time Taylor played against Everton he was the worst player on the pitch by a country mile (he was playing right back, which isn't his preferred position mind).

 

Please play Campbell we want a bigger points difference

 

You are clearly a prat, leave off Sol. This site attracts idiots Bolton for Europe, Barton's Tash and now you.

 

Williamson has been a bit off form in recent games but I would still take him over Taylor. Taylor is lacking match practise and was pretty woeful last time out. With a run of games under his belt i'd probably go with Taylor but now isn't the time to make the change.

 

It's still fairly on topic.

 

Since when were u made mod tash