Off Topic The Gaming Thread - Fifa 13, COD, HALO, SKYRIM...

IMO Sammy doesn't deserve 70, they should put him at maximum 70. Vuckic maybe deserves more than 70.

 

Sammy 65-68
Vuckic 68-71 Imo

 

You can't just make up overall ratings, it';s not that simple, you've got to choose each individual stat and the game generates and overall rating.

You've made both players far too low. To get them that low, you'd have to give them less crap ratings for a lot of things.

After my edits, Sammy is a 71, Vuckic is a 74.

 

Well I based it on where I think they'd get regular games. For instance Burnley, best player is 72. First XI average say 67 But I suppose you do a lot more player ratings than I do

 

They don't just arbitrarily dish out stars, they're based on the first XI (or XVIII?) average rating.

 

Update will be the first week or so of Feb after the January transfers.

 

I suppose, but I think if fifa made our players good enough for 4 1/2 star they would tone some players down

 

Doubt it, they still haven't done QPR's, and that takeover happened months ago.

 

Way too high, basing your ratings are potential.

 

That's what you think but you can't judge me on the overall's you have to see certain stats.

I don't use either of these players anyway really.

 

Overall ratings are weird, and pretty meaningless. I'm Borussia Dortmund, and on player ratings it would suggest Lucas Barrios is very good, but i always find Robert Lewandowski to be better to use.

 

I've got a career mode with Dortmund. Barrios was an absolute machine in my first two seasons, and was top scorer in the league. However this season he's gone off the boil a bit and I'm thinking of dropping him for Lewandowski, who has a quality finish on him.

This is my team:

Guiata (81)

Piszczek (78)
Hummels (87)
Subotic (84)
Ansaldi (81)

Khedira (83)
Bender (82)

Kagawa (84)
Gotzë (87)
My virtual pro (79)

Barrios (84)


I also have Gameiro on the bench who is an 85 but he can't really play as a lone striker.

 

Ba needs to have at least Poacher on Fifa 13, and around an 83 rating if he continues.

 

Manager's son, always seems to get a game..

 

We're seriously short of some well earned accolades.

Ba - clinical finisher
Obertan - speedster
Cabaye - engine, playmaker
Tiote - engine
Raylor - crosser
Colo - tactician, tackler?

 

/\ Its criminal if Colo doesn't get that - also Raylor maybe freekick specialist.

 

He also happens to take penalties....

 

I know he's not exactly Beckham but all the pundits/commentators always mention how well renowned he is for free kick taking. Surprised he didnt get it.

Ba could even have "complete striker". I'm struggling to think of anything he really lacks that you want from a CF.

 

Surely Gutierrez should have the engine trait. Could you name a more hardworking winger?

 

Here's my dortmund team, just started 2nd season

please log in to view this image

Got Goran Pandev as my back up striker, sold Barrios, wasn't performing.

EDIT

That's weird, we both signed Sami Khedira.