Not sure why the controversy around the starc/duckett catch.
Was clearly not out. Guy catches the ball then slides it along the ground while trying to keep his balance. Should have done what always taught to do and catch it and keep your elbows up and roll onto your back if needed.
OTherese coukd say all those times players catch it on boundary then throw it back infield before going over is out as they had the ball in their hand for a second.
Looks caught to me. If he tosses it up in air after the catch and tips over would that be out?
Tbh the main controversy is how stupid can duckett be to try that shot at that point of the day with the ashes on the line