True I can only judge on what I've seen and as Walker is probably the right back I've seen the most he probably stuck in my head the most so I could've forgotten about other players. I was just adding my opinion (possibly biased) to what I felt was already a biased list to begin with to make it more neutral!
No Krul, Cahill over Coloccini and Fletcher over Tiote proves that you know absolutely **** all about football.
Much better, although on current form, I'd put Coloccini over Samba in the top 5 CB's. Having 3 of the top 5 players in their respective positions is fair considering that we're currently 3rd with our first-choice starting XI. There's a reason for it.
That was one game, in which all he did was score a goal, he wasn't amazing at the back, and apart from the goal, wasn't all to spectacular going forward. Sagna, Richards and Johnson are all better players in that position currently. His current level of play just isnt high enough to be considered better than at the very least those three. As for Szczesny not in the top 5, just shows your bias really. He has made a string of top top class saves already this season, and in a time when maybe the seasoned heads are looking a bit fragile (Cech), he looks strong. Also Assou-Ekotto in the top 5, and no Kolarov, really shows how little you know. Ekotto would be lucky to be in the top 10, and at the very least is behind both City left backs. Kolarov is playing simply playing amazingly at the moment, constant threat in attack, and pretty solid in defence. You've also got Tevez in the top 5, who's played all of what 3 games this season, and probably won't ever get another game in the Premiership, just hilarious you think he is the 4th best Striker with little game time, and no hope of ever playing. Aguero, Dzeko and Balotelli are all on better form just inside City alone.
GK: Hart Reina Cech Chesney Begovic RB: Richards Sagna Ivanovic Walker Smalling(?) CB: Vidic Kompany Terry Jagielka TV/Cahill LB: Cole Baines Evra Enrique Ekotto DM: Parker Wilshere Essien Tiote Song/De Jong CM/AM: Silva Modric Nasri VDV Toure/Ramires Winger/WF: Nani Suarez(?) Mata Young Gervinho ST: Aguero RVP Rooney Tevez Dzeko Great thread Finding that 5th winger was the hardest so I classed Suarez as a wide forward and Smalling was the only other person in form at right back at the minute I think!
That's great and all, but what's the point in having him in your squad if he breaks down every two seconds? And in any case, Agger, Vermaelen, Vidic, Ferdinand and Terry are all better than him when fit.
GK: Reina Chesney Krul De Gea Robinson RB: Sagna Johnson Richards Rafael Walker CB: Kompany Vermaelen Vidic Terry Jones LB: Enrique Baines Cole Ekotto Clichy DM: De Jong Lucas Tiote Parker Fletcher CM: Modric Cabaye Ramsey Wilshere Ramires Winger/WF: Silva Mata Gervinho Nani Young ST: Aguero Suarez RVP Rooney Hernandez Here is the definitive list, everyone else is wrong and I'm right
Totally forgot about Song, stick him in place of Fletcher then, as he has been out of form for quite long, and isn't a proper DM like the rest anyway. I'd just ran out of players really, so I put him in there instead. And I'd have Suarez ahead of Van Persie, because Suarez can do things Van Persie can't. Van Persie is a clinical finisher but Suarez makes things happen out of nothing. There's not much in it but I'd have Suarez ahead of Van Persie if I had to choose. And is Walcott better than any of those wingers? The answer is no.
GK: 1.Reina 2.Chensey 3.Cech 4.Hart 5.Krul Right Back: 1.Sagna 2.Richards 3.Ivanovic 4.Walker 5.Da Silva Centre Backs: 1.Kompany 2.King 3.Vidic 4.TV 5.Agger Left Backs: 1.Cole 2.BAE 3.Enrique 4.Baines 5.Clichy Defensive Midfielders: 1.Tiote 2.De Jong 3.Song 4.Parker 5.Lucas Central Midfielders: 1.Wilshere 2.Yaya Toure 3.Modric 4.Ramires 5.Ramsey Wingers/WF: 1.Silva 2.Nani 3.Mata 4.Nasri 5.Gervinho ST: 1.Van Persie 2.Aguero 3.Rooney 4.Van Der Vaart 5.Dzeko
Well firstly I put Sagna and Richards above Walker so I can't be far off. And what has Johnson exactly done this season? When exactly has he been amazing at the back. As for Shesney (however you spell him) he himself has looked shakey too at times. Most recently against Chelsea when he came off his line for no reason and should've got red. And he should've saved the Walker shot too. If you look at most other posts so far you'll see how many others also would put Ekotto in their top 5. So if that really shows how little I know then I guess you feel most others know nothing too. It's fair enough saying you disagree with my opinion but trying to insult my intelligence (and everyone else who put Ekotto in their top 5) just for not sharing your opinion is just not necessary and disrespectful. As for being lucky to get in the top 10 hopefully that's you being biased. Unless you can name 10 better left backs. Don't think you can but try by all means. As for Tevez, you don't become a bad player overnight. He might not have played much this season but last season's top scorer is not **** all of a sudden.
That doesn't matter. All that does matter though is if you don't agree with their opinion then some (not all) gunners think you are not as intelligent as them and can therefore discard your point.
I'll have to disagree about Agger and Vermalen (ironically both of whom have inury problems just as bad as King's and have also played less games this season) being better than King. Ferdinand should be in that injured category too and he is definitely not performing better than King at the moment. Terry has been just as bad recently. I can agree about Vidic though as he truly is a monster.
Just as bad as King, are you joking?!!?!?!? King can't train properly and plays about 6 games a season. The point is King is better than those two when he plays, he certainly IS more injury prone than Agger and TV because he is a permanent crock
Sounds more like Ensil to me! And I'm almost positive that he isn't a Gooner! Maybe King is better than Terry, Ferdinand at the moment, but Agger has been brilliant for me this season when he's played. And If I had to choose between the two of them being fully fit for a whole season, then I'd pick Agger everytime. Suppose its down to opinion really, and there's not that much between them when fit and on form, plus Agger is underrated (imo) outside of Liverpool as people just haven't seen him enough to see his true quality as he's injured for most of the season.
Firstly I didn't mean it literally and exact but I was pointing out they all have serious problems. As for appearances: PL games this season: King = 6 Vermaelen = 3 Agger = 7 Last season: King = 6 Vermaelen = 5 Agger = 16 You can see they all miss lots of games but Vermaelen misses the most. King's main problem is he can hardly ever play one game a week but he has still been managing more games than TV
