Shelvey and McKenzie with a Longstaff in the more advanced role. McKenzie would just sit in front of the back 4
We desperately need both. Both need to be mobile too. We have countless midfielders who just sit, which is ok playing defensive counter, but if we want to actually dictate games, we'll have to start moving around the pitch. Hayden, Shelvey, Longstaff etc aren't going to see us do that. I assume Hayden will still be trying to move back home too.
I think hopeless is harsh. Certainly if your target is top 10, and he is first choice in your midfield, you are gonna struggle to achieve your goals.