Sorry Ralph, you got it wrong again...once Cedric pulled out you should've stuck with the original 4 at the back and played Valery. I hate to say it but defensively JWP is no RWB and we lose his influence too much in the middle.
I was wanting us to revert to a back 4 at HT, when losing to 10 men. But now I'm happy for us to stick as we are.