Bit bored, so here are my POTY musings

Lyle Taylor
Lots of goals
Too many cards

Naby Sarr
Playing well now
Wasn't much good earlier in the season

Chris Solly
Played nearly every game, been OK most of the time
Is fading now though

Patrick Bauer
Consistently good
Dull. And he's leaving soon.

Don't think anybody else is in with a shout really.
Phillips is doing well but missed a third of the season.
Cullen is classy but I don't think he's done enough over the whole season.
Same (only a bit less so) foir Bielik.
Reeves has had his moments but not enough of them.
Aribo... Sorry, not enough.

YPOTY - Give it to Lapslie

 

Good thread @lardiman

I will vote for Naby Sarr.

He has morphed from accident prone donkey into a formidable and dominating centre half at this level. Not many players come back from being a laughing stock in the fan's eyes - he has Blocked loads of our supporters on Twitter - so well done to him for showing personality and character

Taylor has let his standards drop in recent weeks.

Bielik and Cullen have both been good loans.

Phillips and Aribo have had good seasons and will go on to have good careers, although neither with us.

Fosu, Pratley, Marshall, Parker & Vetekole have been useless. Reeves has been a big let down again. And Solly has seen his form dip alarmingly this season.

 

I am going to vote for Karlan Grant … we always lose our POTY so as Karlan has already left that will not be a problem

 

You need to have watched the players play before you can vote for them


()

 

I'd rather give it to one of our own, but couldn't vote against Josh Cullen. Consistently classy, too good for L1. Sarr and Phillips deserve credit for persevering in the face of knock-backs, but for me it's no contest, Cullen.

 

Can I vote?

 

naby, solly or cullen for me. if naby continues to be "rested" for pearce i think i'll go solly.

 

You don't look old enough.

 

You must be a worried man this week

 

No you don't

 

i think solly's always got to be in with a shout because he's home grown and aint gonna disappear like a few of the recent ones have.

he'll be the new SCP in time.

 

I am not at all sure that it is physically possible for Solly to do a Tunnel Jump without breaking down ?

 

not physically, but he'll have the same sort of appeal @Royston Vasey has for SCP. he'll be welcome back anytime, in whatever role he wants.

as long as it's not like keith peacocks - they roll him out when no one else is available. just have to wake him up and retrieve him from the vista lounge.

 

I'll take that as a compliment.

 

POTY results last night -

1. Lyle Taylor

2. Naby Sarr

3. Josh Cullen (he will have a very good career)

Young POTY - George Lapslie

Thank you to Lyle for his goals, and for his conduct in general, which has made him a popular figure at Charlton.

Well done to Naby Sarr for proving his doubters wrong. He had been outstanding this season.

 

That is how I would have marked it.

 

Josh Parker.

 

Aribo possibly unlucky not to figure.

 

Taylor deserves it. Apart from being our talisman he's carried the burden up front all season and capped it all with probably goal of the season. Well done young Naby for running him close.