The FINAL Banner Poll! Closed! (Waiting for Mick, stop asking!)

Sorry man! Locked it to save confusion. I'll replace the picture in the original post with that one! yes?

 

BEAR IN MIND!!
The fade off at the bottom isn't a long way past the bottom of the red "post new thread"
button. Some are in a different post code below this tidemark in the visuals!

 

*Shameless self vote*

 

I preferred the old number 7.

 

So the downfall begins.

CURSE YOU NOT606 **** THAT RUINS MY BANNER!

 

Was a toss up between 7 and 8 for me, 8 looks more pleasing on the eye not to sure why, but the picture of Sir Bobby is a must so I have gone for 7!

 

Goddam - guys, I can't make a number7 ALL of you like? Nobody seemed to like
Saylors peeing himself expression in the first one did they?

After all this, one of the chosen banner's players better not break their bleedin leg!!
Make sure the chads are fully punched or there'll need to be a recount AH (AND thanks
for updating the picture BTW!!).

 

Just for the record i can change the players on mine as well, as long as i can find them facing the correct angle that is, i could even have Bobby Robson as well as some older and newer players. I can even get rid of the players altogether and move the badge into the center.

Personally for me, dont vote on the players, vote on the style and the composition/fit of the banner, as most on all of them can be changed to suite the masses.

 

I totally agree with this approach Steve - it's the idea of the composition or "creative" that should be judged as details can always be changed within reason.

In my work, usually three totally different options for something like this banner are presented to the client who then decides which tangent idea they like and then that is further developed. It's rare that an original idea see's it's way to the end result although in my experience the most creative thing is usually the first thing designed as it 'downloads' from the imagination into reality.

In the end, this is a fair consideration for all the proposals shown here. It's a challenge to get the right pose/expression or even sufficient quality of image of these players and gel them into a layout that gels together. Especially when elements like the NUFC logo are incorporated onto it.

All these creative considerations and ideas hanging in the balance at the mercies of a democratic vote!!! lol

 

I only get a tiny thumbnail?

please log in to view this image

 

8 looks better because of the deeper black involved.

 

7 and can we hurry it up I'm pissed off seeing Nolan .

 

It was all I had at the time haha, sorry. It was the clickable one that you put up in the other thread, so it was still good. Doesn't make much of a difference really, but I've swapped them now!

 

Seven again for me. Just.

 

Vote for Pedro....... Number 3

 

I will pick number 8 because of the players Cabaye, Ben Arfa, Tiote have to be on the banner but I like number 7 background, surely somebody can do better then any of them with Ben Arfa, Cabaye, Tiote, Santon and Saylor or Colo on the banner.

 

4&3 for me buy can't decide which one!

 

Going for number 7 too. Looks awesome!

I swear Colo was wearing the old shirt before though...

 

In effect, there's not a massive difference between number4 and number8 as far as content
goes although the black is stronger, it could look a bit flat in colour; why it's nice to see SJP.

I reckon HBA could get a squeeze into number7 looking past Tiote's shoulder I guess! lol ;-)
Don't want to make it look too busy as that's been the main concern on number4...

 

lol - Collo and Tiote DID have older shirts!