good morning all. I am now collecting votes and actions. Haven't paid a blinds bit off attention over weekend
first off: the list of dead as a recap List of dead 1 Astro: jailor 2 TOBES: Vigilante 3 Swantastic: consigilieri 4 AFCFTW: unknown 5 chaos: doctor 6 JigsawKlopp: Beat cop 7 Musty: Vampire 8 I am Groot: Amnesiac 9 Zanjinho: Vampire 10 Style: Hooker 11 Mbemba: Serial killer 12 Lordjonjo: Doctor 13 ACS: SWAT 14 Solid air: Winston wolf 15 Valley: Vampire That leaves 7 players
What you on about i've said loads or at least as others. Admittedly i haven't been on much late at night (very much RHC like). Mafiavote: Tennis Let's see: we have 2 people who are claiming detective roles. Could they both be detectives? Hell knows was Valley was. It just said hew as a vampy boy.
All I'd say is wouldn't be logical for me to come out and claim the detective role if I wasn't a detective after 2 people before me had already claimed it (and one killed). Far easier to claim a diff role. Btw I investigated you on Friday
ACS was swat, so Bobby must be one of the godfather or ambusher. Bobby is definitely Mafia in that case. Tennis must be evil of some sort as he claimed detective role as well. We we need to lynch tennis and Bobby. Need to all decide which one we're going for and stick with it.
So what roles are left? Godfather Mafioso Detective Witch Vampire hunter Medium SWAT Is that right? What role do you think the inactive Obi is? If of course he is inactive
Hi guys, Nice and quiet on the weekend, you didn't miss much MITO! there are 7 players left, claimed roles included: 1@Agent Moyes' eyebrows (obi) - ??? 2@Beardsley's Stylist - SWAT? 4@Red Hadron Collider - VH? 7@InBiscanWeTrust - Detective? 13@Sir Tennisball - Detective 16@BobbyD - ??? 18@ademuzzy - Medium? Roles left in bold, bear in mind we probably have a Vamp so one of these numbers is too high by one so I put a question mark next to them, and the ANY role is probably one of the Twon Random role claims so should actually be 0: %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% EVIL --------------------------------------- MAFIA - 2 Godfather - ?? Mafioso - ?? DEAD - Random 1: Consigilieri - swantastic DEAD - Random 2: Hooker - Style DEAD - Random 3: Winston wolf? - Solid_Air VAMPIRES - 1? (could be 0 but VH is not vigilante yet afaik) DEAD - Vampire 1 - mustyfrog DEAD - Vampire 2 - Zanjinho (Gerrez) was Back Stabber DEAD - Vampire 3 - Valley Vampire 4? - Could be one of town roles or Witch (VH is not vigilante yet) SK - 0 DEAD - SK - Mbemba You're A Womble (Nev) BACK STABBER - 0 DEAD - Back Stabber - Zanjinho (Gerrez) made Vamp WITCH - 1? (Could be Vamp) Witch - ?? --------------------------------------- NEUTRAL - 0 DEAD - Amnesiac - I am Groot (Sebb/Trev) --------------------------------------- ANY - 1? (likely to be one of Town Random role claims) ?? - ?? (likely to be one of Town Random role claims) DEAD - mafia Hooker OP: "oh this one is fun... I am going to pick ONE role from all the roles listed here and that will be added to game. THERE WILL BE TWO ANYS...Could be town, could be neutral could be vamp, could be mafia... etc. However it won't be a second jailor or godfather. you only get one of those" --------------------------------------- TOWN - 4? (could be 3 if Vamp but town) DEAD - Jailer - Astro DEAD - Cop 1: Beat Cop - Jigsawklopp Cop 2: Detective - Tennisball (IBWT claiming same role, could be Random Town or Any as well but unlikely) DEAD - Town Doctor - Chaos DEAD - SWAT - ACS Vampire Hunter - RHC? DEAD - Town killer: Vigilante - Tobes DEAD - Good Samaritan 1: Resurrector? - AFC? Good Samaritan 2: Medium? - Ademuzzy? DEAD - Random Town 1: Doctor 2 - Lord Jonjomort Random Town 2: ?? - ?? (Swat - Beardsley? IBWT - Detective?) OP: "This is actually a very needed category: Just as with the ANY category this one allows wriggle room for players trying to hide to have a duplicate role lie to any town. There will be TWO players assigned their roles from the above town roles at random (except for jailor) Coudl be two detectives, two lookouts, there could be 4 could Samaritans in this game etc etc. take nothing for granted. Weed out the bad guys but it won't be easy." %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% EDIT: We dont know Valley's role yet all we know he died a Vamp, and claimed to be a Beat Cop which could also take up one of the town roles if true)
Good/Town roles: So we have 2 definite town roles alive: VH - RHC (no other claimants) Cop 2: Detective - Tennisball (IBWT claims too. Either he's lying or could be Random Town or Any roles, see reasoning below) If Ademuzzy is the Medium then he becomes the Good Samaritan 2 role, and Afc is the Good Samaritan 1 role (Resurrector) as the two are linked. I believe this is the case and there have been no counter claims. Then we have either 1 or 2 more roles for town that are variable: Variable role 1: Random Town 2 (Random Town 1 was Jonjo as he was the second Doctor along with Chaos) Possible Variable role 2: Any (OP states the ANY role could Evil, Neutral or Town. The first Any role was the Mafia Hooker so I'm assuming the second one is town, but that's not guaranteed.) Evil roles: 2 Mafia roles and the Witch are self explanatory. We could have 0, 1 or 2 Vamps, they can't convert Mafia so if alive they either converted Town or the Witch. If they're all dead the VH (RHC) will become Vigilante. -------------------------------------- Summary So it all comes down to who you trust. IBWT and I claim the same role, either one of us is lying or the 2nd person was allocated the Detective role as the Random Town 2 or Any role. In my opinion the status of each player is: Confirmed town, but could be Vamp except for VH: RHC - VH ademuzzy - Medium Tennisball - Detective Then we have 2 more town roles that are variable, this could be 1 if the Any is evil or neutral but I think it's town. These guys could be Vamps as well. So far two players have claimed town roles in addition to the above: Beardsley's Stylist - SWAT InBiscanWeTrust - Detective then we have 2 players who have not claimed a role as far as I can recall, I'll update if I missed it: Agent Moyes' eyebrows (obi) BobbyD Obi seems inactive, Bobby has been shown to be innocent in investigations by Valley (who was a vamp) and IBWT (claims detective). Both stated that BobbyD could be Godfather. IBWT said he was innocent at first but after RHC also voted BobbyD he said his investigation listed Godfather as one of the options. Mafiavote: BobbyD I think BobbyD looks the most guilty, has not claimed a role either. I still think IBWT was covering for BobbyD and initially flagged him as innocent, and then only voted for him after a few others did. So even if BobbyD is Godfather I'm suspicious of IBWT. But as I've stated above there is a chance that IBWT is a town role, if he got allocated either the Random Town 2 or ANY role. EDIT: We dont know Valley's role yet all we know he died a Vamp, and claimed to be a Beat Cop which could also take up one of the town roles if true)
Oh, and my investigation was a bust yesterday, I decided to go for Valley instead of BobbyD and he was killed before it took place. I had already investigated IBWT and Obi was obviously inactive, so those were my two options.
I don't know what to make of Obi's inactivity, he was active initially which is why MITO did not kill him off I guess. If he's town then we have a problem as we have too many guys claiming town roles. I don't believe he's the Mafia Goon as they have been killing, it could happen as the Godfather would then do the killing but he would have shown up in one of our investigations by now I would hope, especially if IBWT is really a detective as well. If he was the Godfather then the Goon could select the target and do the killing so it's plausible, but again I think the Goon may have been spotted in an investigation by now. If he's the Witch then it makes a bit more sense as we don't know of any confirmed witch actions yet. My guess would be that he's either the Witch or a Town/Any role. I don't think he's much of a threat while he's inactive so not worth wasting a lynch vote on, if we kill off the Vamps then RHC can always Vigilante him if we don't know of a very suspicious mafia target. But I think out priority is to kill off active evil guys before worrying about Obi, unless he becomes active of course.
This is what MITO said when he decided on inactives I've had a quick look and I don't think Obi has been active at all. Looking at the roles the only one that makes sense to me is Godfather. I'm pretty sure the Witch has been active and I don't think MITO would want this role to be inactive
Okay boys, i'm going to have to come out with it. I'm the veteran and cannot be attacked else you will die. It's best to lynch me if you guys are no closer so that you can gather information on the remaining mafia that are left over. From the information i have gathered on this board: Obi - unknown, guys been silent Tennis - claims detective Beardsley - claims Swat Ademuzzie - claims Medium RHC - claims vampire hunter IBWT - claims detective There are in my view 2 Mafia vs 4 towns vs 1 vampire. After tonight there will probably be 2 mafia vs 2 town vs 2 vampires based on me being lynched. I suspect Tennis or IBWT of being the vampire or godfathers as they can't both be detectives. Likewise, one of these two was working with Valley who was a known vampire (both backing him up) so they definitely wanted to take out town/mafia, Makes sense for solid to go as mafia but initially Tennis and Valley both wanted to take out IBWT,only changing when everyone didn't jump on this which is why i make Tennis 90% Vampire so probably detective turn vampire. On this basis it makes far more sense to stop the Vampires from growing as not only are they killing town, they are actually growing their number. RHC you must target Tennis tonight. IBWT has been shady all game. First he claims a role that he knows he can hide behind as their are multiple cops. Then he claims i've been investigated and i'm innocent (as what valley says). Now he's changed his story that actually i'm one of 3 roles, which bascally says i'm the godfather. You don't get anymore suspicious than that. I do not think there is a witch around. If there was the witch is probably a vamp now. In fact just reading the witch she is basically a detective so one of those 2 are looking even more shady. For the time being i'm leaving my MafiaVote: Tennis on unless RHC can confirm he's going to take out tennis tonight
