Reading back through lad's, are we 100% sure that Tennis is mafia? We KNOW solid is Mafia so he would be the safer bet tonight incase Tennis isn't mafia? I say we lynch SOLID tonight and go for Tennis tomorrow.
I onvestagtee him he might before he died? wednesday at 9:18 is when I got the pm from mito saying nev was covered in blood of that helps.
Right, just like I had to be evil yesterday because Nev and I had the same role? All it means is that ONE of us is evil, either me or you, it's up to our peers to decide our fate. I'm an open book, people can judge me on my voting (including lynching a Mafia), my posts and my investigation results which bear up to scrutiny. Until today no one has claimed my cop role except Nev. You, on the other hand, were reintroduced into the game due to Tobes' inactivity, so the logical conclusion is that Tobes had a key role and it needed filling. You claim you're detective which is not exactly a key role, it's not like Jailer, VH which are the key town roles. However my investigation lists you as the Witch, which IS a key role and would make sense if that role was inactive. We don't have any evidence of witch actions so it may well have been inactive prior to your return. On top of that you've hardly been constructive to town, and did not reveal your role yesterday when pretty much all town roles had been claimed and we were making good progress on figuring out who is hiding among town roles. The votes will decide, either way the game's up and you'll be known as the witch after nightfall at the latest.
Didnt need to reveal my role when you two claimed the same. Meant that I knew one of you was going to swing and you're boring evil so perfect. If I counter claimed makes it 3 people, town even more confused and the chance that they lynch me and leave you both alive and the SK killing again lastly night. Like i said, needed to claim it yesterday as couldn't have town trusting you.
Bye you say I've not been constructive to town. I've named 2 evil players, confirmed one town player in ademuzzy and also backed up valleys claims. Why add long rambling posts when a simple, nev and tennis are both evil, Valley is trustworthy so if he says solid and style were Mafia then he can be believed. If I know something, might as well keep it short and sweet rather than try write long posts to confuse people.
Hmmmm..... you two have got me in a quandry: MafiaVote: Withdraw Vote Can't work out which one of you two are the evil ones... unless we have loads of detectives around! i'm a detective too . Seriously though, both have good arguments: Here's my summary of the two: Tennis: Positives - Voted Mafia Swanstastic (although i will play it down as it was the very first vote and some late voting went on to remove swans) - He named Nev directly yesterday as the SK - Hasn't done anything massively suspicious Negatives - Not much helpful input until yesterday, just so happened whoever he investigated died or was known (ACS 3rd day) until Nev last night. Are his detective skills really that bad!? IBWT Positives - Been openly backing Valley and named the three he suspects inc Nev - Make a good point at not revealing yesterday Negatives - Been quiet like Tennis - Only feeding bits of information I guess the other thing we need to do is wonder: - Do we believe Tennis really investigated IBWT last night out of curiosity or is it just a convenient story for today - Do we know what Role MITO would have kept when he allowed IBWT back in. I think a detective role is just as important if not more than the witch. Anyone got anymore to add?
I investigated the key players that I feel are good Mafia players, reason being if I know they're town then great I can follow their lead and back them up, if they're evil I can get them lynched. IBWT was very quiet since he came back which is out of character, especially if we're all discussing roles and who could be hiding among town, in previous games he has usually led that kind of discussion. Night 1 - Investigate Astro. Result: No result Night 2 - Investigate I am Groot (Sebb/Trev). Result: Amnesiac, Vampire, Escort or hooker Night 3 - Investigate ACS. Result: Godfather, SWAT or ambusher Night 4 - Investigate Mbemba You're A Womble (Nev). Result: Doctor, Serial Killer, backstabber Night 5 - Investigate IBWT. Result: Survivor, Witch or Vampire hunter
I also backed ACS' claim of SWAT when it was not confirmed, as Beardsley had claimed the role too and other Random Town roles were being discussed. Of the 4 town role claims I mentioned that I trusted ACS' claim, and for me the other 3 players were vying for 2 random town roles. I could not come out with much more than that as it would reveal that I was detective, however I hoped that ACS and a few other town roles would realise that I had info so would be a cop role. I kept mentioning that the second cop role was still unknown, I couldn't be any more blatant than that. What do I know though, I'm just a stupid copper
ACS and Jonjo why did you guys die last night? We wouldn't be having this conversation if we had two known town backing me up...
Based on my conversations with the dead. Biscan's story doesn't add up. If he is claiming that he investigated nev on Wednesday night then that means he investigated Valley on Tuesday. MITO's update suggested Biscan came back into the game on Tuesday nightfall. However, regardless of that, if he investigated nev on Wednesday night then why wouldn't he have included an investigation result for Thursday night? He is trying to play it safe and only have already confirmed investigation results. If he tried to claim a new one and got it wrong then he'd drop himself in it. If he had originally meant that he investigated nev on Wednesday then he would 100% have mentioned a Thursday investigation.
I did mention Biscan was only feeding bits of information. Be interesting what he says On the other hand Tennis said I'm not sure that stacks up. You say you investigated the "good" mafia players yet you've included ACS . You had ample opportunity to get IBWT beforehand when he was acting "suspiciously" quiet so i'm a little perplexed at the moment
