Off Topic Easiest poster on the PL board to wind up?

Nope, as explained it has no basis from the Qur'an or Hadiths, its practiced by Shia's but has no foundation in Islam.

 

please log in to view this image

 

Verse 3:28

 

Si sigh

If you want answers then you need to clue up on the topic

Shariah isn't simply legal system

 

a. Would you like Sharia law to replace our current legal system in the UK ?

b. Should homosexuality be illegal in the UK?

c. What should the punishment if any be for apostasy in the UK?

 

What about it?

 

Can you answer questions b and c then ?

 

b. Should homosexuality be illegal in the UK ?

c. What if any punishments should be given to apostates in the UK ?

 

Why you focussed on homosexuality? Coming out?

Islam doesn't discriminate against homosexuals

Hadh rulings are in hands of ruling authority, so the answer to the apostasy question can't be answered. The main issue agreed upon is to try and bring apostates back unto the fold

 

Enoch Powell is desperate tonight

 

You seem to be getting too caught up in the word sharia as media portrays that as something really bad and Muslims are here to take over...

There is no basis for Sharia to be dominant here in the UK as its not a Muslim country, Muslims live by Sharia every day as its their way of life and there is nothing there that contradicts or stops Muslims practicing their way of life from the English law.

Simply put there is no need for Sharia Law in the UK as such.

Again what people do is their business, even in true Islamic countries what people do in their homes is their business, whether they bang one guy or four guys. The ruling is only in public if they start to practice it as in carry out an sexual act in public then there are rulings based on that but its a long thing and this forum isn't the place to discuss as you could never have a meaningful debate.

Again what people practice or believe is their business, there is no compulsion, there is rulings when people apostate and start making trouble in public in a true Islamic country and its a big subject on its own right.

 

I think Duncan wants to move to Dubai and is seeking clarification of the rules and regs

 

Have you read the whole thing ever or just the 3:28?

 

So b. Islam has no problem with homosexuals?
OK.

c. The guy or girl are not coming back to the fold they have decided that Islam is not for them .
They were born into the religion but now they are 21 they don't want anything to do with it.
Should there be a punishment?

 

No I can't read Arabic so I have to rely on translation to English.

 

Funny thing about guys like Duncan and the while gay thing is that if the went to middle eastern countries they would be shocked

Take the Qatar world cup and the whole "they don't like gays" anyone been there will tell you that men walking about holding hands is normal.

Even in Abu Dhabi and Dubai etc the people who have got in trouble is for making out between man and woman.

Talk about false premise

 

Follow the conversation sigh

Islam doesn't discriminate against homosexuals is what I said

And they don't have to be 21 they can leave when reaching puberty and no punishment as anyone prior to that follows the religion of their parents

Sorry pal but you are out of your depth here mislead by right wing websites

 

Care to explain what point you are making with that verse?

 

You should be in charge of reforming Islam Fan if more people had your tolerance then there would be less problems.
Unfortunately the Wahabi mosques that the Saudis promote don't share your interpretation of your faith.

 

Islam doesn't need reforming

People need to stop being dumbcunts