surprised tbh, he was pretty decent for us, since we sold him our left side of defence has been appalling.
Im not sure what happened with him, because he was quality first time round when we had him. Most of us were chuffed when Keano paid 6m to bring him back! This time round he has just looked uninterested, gave stupid fouls away and is constantly injured! A few Leeds fans im friends with have told me he was useless for the aswell!
The guy was useless for Leeds, we all thought we was finally getting a decent left back, oh how we were wrong. Eventually got injured half way into his loan and never got back into the squad, replaced by Villa's Eric Lichaj. He was decent going forward but he was a right donkey defending just look for the highlights of Leeds 3-1 home win over Bristol City, donkey! in my opinion he isn't good enough for West Ham.