Villa In For Smithies?

They can fook right off!

 

You couldn't blame Smithies for going that is for sure. We are a total basket case at the moment. His prospects will be far stronger in a team like AV.

 

It will give an indication of our ambition if we resist selling in this window. All the clubs at the top of the Championship will launch cherry-picking bids to strengthen and if we sell we are admitting we cannot compete...

 

At the moment, Smithies is the only thing holding us back from a plummet to the third tier. There would surely be huge unrest among the fans if we let him go

 

I know it's Christmas and all that but can we have none of this being rational nonsense please, I'll stick with my original comment, they can fook right off!

 

Not sure that's true, we've just lost 5 games on the trot, how does he help?

 

We would have lost them by a much greater margin without him I suspect.

 

sell hiim definately because our number two is even better ingram is another dave seaman in the making,from the money buy a couple of black strikers
that can fire us into the play offs even if we drop this season ollie can rebuild its all about strikers selling a lot of tallent this january is important if we are going down so what we rebuild,weve done it before and we will do it again

 

They may be true but a loss is a loss whether by 1 or 6. Smithies is not the only thing holding us back from a plummet to the third tier as Goldhawk suggests unfortunately..

 

I wouldn't argue with that, but at least Smithies is able to keep us in games longer, as with the penalty save against Villa. We then have a chance of getting something out of the game.

 

If you take the Villa game, our general defence was so poor that Smithies had to make a number of potentially match-rescuing saves. After about the fifth, Villa got one through - but !ooking forward, if we manage to stay in this division, then on current form, it will have been Smithies that made the difference imo, keeping the score against down so that as and when we actually manage to hit the opponents' net, it converts to points

 

Ingram is a pretty good stopper too. A good price for Smithies and those funds used to buy us a striker might actually be decent business.

 

£4m would be a pitiful amount. He's too good for our shower but we should be getting double that.

 

You're at it again, remember this club of ours doesn't do sensible!

 

the other side of the coin is if we dont sell smithies we will lose ingram for a very poor fee dont forget ingrim is currently also 4million rated and he needs first team action to get better no keeper of his ability will stay at a club in the reserves
so lets get this transfer going as quick as possible ,also i think smithies could be going bald

 

He deserves better things than being at a ramshackle club like ours.

 

100% this. More like £7m perhaps?

 

I don't think 8-10 is unreasonable given the market we are in, his age and ability. Villa aren't afraid of throwing money around.

He's got everything you'd want from a goalkeeper and is probably three years from his peak. Plus we'll probably go down if we lose him so I wouldn't be rushing to sell.

 

Agreed Watford. Poor show if they sell.