Sullivan Signs

Martin never impressed me would much prefer Andy Reid he's still a free agent too

 

Heard reid off to forest I wanna keep Robbie cos he`s a charlton fan !

 

I liked Lee Martin, but he always seemed to fall just short of his potential imo, but I wouldn't complain if he came back on a permanent deal. The more competition for positions from players under contract the better.

 

Would love Martin back. Would be our 'classiest' player. He just strikes me as being someone who plays in many different positions so never cements himself or makes one particular role his own. Would be a great addition though, however it seems Jewell likes him.

 

I would be happy with Martin back too, this signing doesn't thrill me too much as I am happy with Elliott in goal and don't think we need strengthening in that position as much as others, Elliott in my opinion is definately championship quality too.

 

Sullivan looked a better keeper than Elliott, which is a shame as he's Charlton through and through. Plus Elliott has picked up too many injuries over the past couple of seasons. I can see Elliott leaving now but to be honest I think Sullivan will end up being better.

As for the talk of Martin coming back, that really worries me. He was awful and I was pleased when he went back. I don't see any reasoon why we should get him back.

 

Fantastic signing, hope we keep Elliot as well! To have two excellent keepers fighting it out for the Number 1 spot can only be good for Charlton!!