Separate names with a comma.
10/10. According to the ref in my house, the VAR system prioritises the refs on field decisions. That priority can create inconsistency between...
That is again an answer to neither question. The protocol highlights clear and obvious error, not as you have posted mere error, why does the...
That is not an answer to either question. I will add/alter a question. The protocol highlights clear and obvious error, not as you have posted...
So, clear and obvious error, not as you have posted mere error? Where in the protocol does it state VAR can over rule the refs decision?
The VAR protocol says so Video Assistant Referee (VAR) protocol | IFAB (theifab.com)
You have misunderstood how VAR works. VAR does not overrule the referee. VAR doesn't allow a penalty. VAR evaluates if there has been a clear and...
The referee gave the goal. It is very possible VAR would not have become involved if there was no penalty. VAR's is not there to agree with...
VAR did not.
My answer is in posts 101 and 103.
As I posted, "Looking at their posts I think it would be beyond me". I can confirm a few posts later, it is.
That is vague, not specific. What was close about it?
Why do you think specifically it is harsh?
I think the rules are very clear. In this case I do not think it was a penalty. I have explained why. Do you think it was a penalty, or not?
Looking at their posts I think it would be beyond me. If VAR don't see a error the ref does not review his decision. Dermot Gallagher reviewing...
When humans move our bodies our arms move. We use bipedal movement. To not display bipedal movement when moving would be unnatural. The player in...
Everybody has heard of Blackburn, Fulham, Lincoln, Leeds and Notts county, but who is that other team Kettering mention? [IMG]
Have they? I did not glean that. The consistent theme was that the Huddersfield players arm/hand was in a natural position. It appears unless HTFC...
Rebecca Welch | DATM | HTAFC (proboards.com) I think we will have to work harder. As Seen on TV | RefChat - The Refereeing Forum This is...
I think its an interesting topic. The ball did hit his hand/arm and there are very many scenarios where this is not an offence. Speaking to a ref...
What do you think the referee should have given v West Ham? Your point was VAR would have given the decision versus Huddersfield. Why would VAR...
